October 2019 by Nichole w
Pizza was AMAZING. Honestly, probably the best pizza I've ever had. And the crust, OH MAN, delicious. It's a tight space, but it just fits in with that rustic, quirky atmosphere that I loved. The service was good, and our waitress wearing the blue fright farm sweatshirt was a total sweetheart. She was great. It was a little slow getting drinks and greeted, but I'm a waitress. I get it, things get crazy. ONLY complaint is, the woman who brought our beer to us wasnt very friendly and didnt crack a smile or respond any of the times we said thank you. Just a beer on the table, asked if our IDs had been checked (in a kinda snarky "you're not 21" way, not exactly asking. I have a baby face, I know), and walked off a little coldish after we said thank you without saying a word. Could have been an off day for her, but it just threw us off after our waitress was so nice. Either way, we will be back. Just cant beat that pizza.
October 2019 by Jaya Weaver
Service was not great. These stuffed peppers were okay. 2 were very hot and spicy and 2 were not. The pasta was horrible. I ordered the Olio- and it was so dry! No oil at all. There were about 3 pieces of sliced garlic and dry pasta. I added the marinara from the stuffed peppers to try to give it enough moisture to eat. We asked the waitress for more "sauce" or Olive oil or something to get it down. She brought marinara. I won't be back. Not worth it.
October 2019 by Chris Randall
Delicious food and wonderful staff! 6 stars out of 5.
October 2019 by Milan S.
I have never written a review, but felt compelled to for this experience. My boyfriend and I just ate here for dinner. We received horrible service from the younger blonde waitress with a southern accent. We had just opened our menus and she asked if we were ready to order. We stated we needed a minute. She returned back quickly and stormed off when we said we needed another minute as we were not sure. Then, she came back after us waiting for 10 minutes or so. She started writing down our order and said she had to serve another table first. She then came back and asked if we were "finally" ready. We ordered and then when time came for the check, she added costs to our order. She charged us for water, which was free! Also, added extra tax. While checking out, the lady in charge was much nicer and didn't charge us for water and extra costs. Other than service, the veggie pizza was mediocre. Would not recommend this place for someone who is vegetarian and asking for better service as well as prices.
September 2019 by Krista Ritchie
Hostess extremely RUDE! Dirty plates,no straws, waitress not very friendly either! However, the pizza was amazing!!!
September 2019 by Fred H Harshberger III
Fantastic Pizza! Great staff and reasonable prices!!!!!
September 2019 by Steven W.
Solid 3.5 stars here at Siriannis Cafe. There are only a few restaurants in Davis. A couple seemed beer/alcohol centric so I opted for Sirianni's. It was a Sunday night, about 7 p.m., and the place was about half-full. The sign a few steps in read "wait to be seated" and I became slightly concerned when I was not promptly addressed. However, the two young waitresses were definitely preoccupied and not ignoring me. Still, I felt somebody should be at the sign and cash register to greet diners. However, After being seated I felt everything was reasonably prompt, Including the food. The side salad was brought out within a few minutes and the "oh mike goss" pasta plate soon followed. This plate was portioned for two reasonable people or one person looking for a carbohydrate coma. (Warning: The "oh Mike Goss" plate had a little kick to it like a sicilian cuisine plate. The young waitress said it was one of her favorites but did not mention the Heat.) My cup of water was refilled as needed. Did I mention the two waitresses were young? Before I left I learned both teenagers. They do great for teenagers, but don't expect 40 year old professional waitress quality service. I look forward to my second visit to see where it goes from here. Will my 3.5 stars be rounded up? Or down?
September 2019 by Mariam H.
Our second time in Davis and this time decided to try the pizza restaurant that always seemed very busy. Big mistake! I normally do not write less than three star reviews, but in this instance I really feel travelers with limited time in the area should know my experience at this establishment. You are on vacation - you should have a tasty meal that you are spending your hard earned money on! First off, all the decorations that clutter the place are dirty with lots of dust settled upon them. If a guest can see a film of dust or water spots from where they are seated, imagine what is lurking about that they can't see.... Second, the pizza isn't very appetizing in my opinion. The crust lacked any flavor. I imagine it is what cardboard would taste like only the cardboard would have more flavor. We ordered a pizza with chicken and artichokes and other veggies. The chicken was dry. The artichokes were the best part and I picked them out of everything else. Third, our pizza took forever to arrive at our table. Tables seated after us (even large groups!) received their orders long before us. A restaurant with hospitality would have at least offered an apology or a reason or even an offer of free soft drinks! I told my husband the next night I'd be happier with a frozen pizza from the Shop n' Save down the street and warm it up in our cabin. We drove all the way to Elkins instead for Mexican food (Hellbender Burritos was closed otherwise would have stayed in Davis). One plus for Siriannis is they offer very cheap, heavy pours of average tasting wine. Needless to say I drank alllll of my glass long before our pizza arrived.
September 2019 by Lori J.
I've always heard great things, so I had to make a trip up to check it out! Went on a Saturday night and it was slammed! Their seating is a little cramped when they're so packed, but I love the ambiance of this place (it's very... Davis/Thomas). Got a salad and pizza. Some of the best crust I've had! LOVED this pizza Will be back (maybe on a less crowded day lol)
August 2019 by B M.
What a great place to eat. We started with the sausage stuffed pepper with cheese and the flavor was spicy deliciousness. I pretty much licked the plate - by soaking up the sauce with yummy garlic bread. The pizza was good- we got the artery clogger. Lots of meat and the sauce was yum. We got a side of Ranch and that was the best Ranch I've ever had. I dipped everything in it and took it home. They make it homemade and it is so mouthwatering delicious you have to try it. We ended with a lemon cake that was perfect. Great meal and we will be back as often as we can :)
August 2019 by James M.
Great food, great service, highly recommend. We got the Angel hair pasta and a steak sub, the steak sub is done different then traditional but extremely flavorful!
August 2019 by Emery M.
If you're ever in Davis Wv it's worth stopping in food is good the service is good great atmosphere but remember to bring cash they don't take any kind of plastic but they got a ATM inside it's worth yo
August 2019 by Karen Sanney
We visited Blackwater Falls for a few days and we ate at Sirianni's Cafe twice and both times we enjoyed it so much! The pizza crust is so good and the pizza ingredients were fresh. My daughter had the Garlic Wedges and she loved them. If you like garlic, you will too. Our server was Lauren and she was so friendly and attentive. We even recommend Sirianni's to a couple we talked to at the lodge and they came back and told us they enjoyed going there and thanked us for recommending it to them. You need to try it too!!!
August 2019 by Abner87
Excellent service from my waitress(tall girl) and delicious food. The only suggestion is that the blonde/short waitress should be more kind, she is too rough and rude throwing plates in the table and moving things around; bad attitude in general that doesn't looks good I just want to think it was just a bad day for her. Also, if your are not from the area, beware they only take cash or check even though they have ATM(add. fee) . 8/19/19
August 2019 by Duane B.
It was late...after a long day of shopping and hiking...we needed to recharge. Sirianni's Cafe was our late night pick...and a great pick it was. Our group of four ordered a crazy amount of food and every dish was excellent. I particularly liked the stuffed hot peppers. The large cheese & sausage pie was perfectly done. Large caesar salad accompanied a huge spaghetti and meatballs dish....excellent! A bottle of chianti wine served by our wonderful waitress, Gracie, made the experience even better. Perfect ending to a perfect day. Many thanks to the hard working staff...yes John Paul that definitely includes you! We recommend this place and would certainly go back.
August 2019 by Lisa S. Estes
Always a great place for our entire family to enjoy subs and pizza! Love the ambiance! Food is always consistent and delicious!!
August 2019 by Chris B.
I usually don't go around complaining about service or attitude, focusing on the food. First, the attitude about our service dog was very negative, and full of false statements about the law. We showed the dogs documentation, but it was discussion that spiteful. Then the chefs salad had no tomatoes and huge thickly cut carrots, two tiny pieces of ham and minimal cheese. I told the waitress that I never had a salad without tomatoes. She said, "Well you ate it". I said, "I wasn't given a choice". I pointed this out before I ate, and then again at the register when she made her statement. Not likely to visit this place again. It suffers from lack of competition.
August 2019 by Desiree Rudolph
This is Davis’s little Italian spot. Lots of pizzas and pastas. We had the XXX pizza which had a little bit of everything. This crust was no joke maybe the best crust I’ve ever had. It was crisp but so fluffy inside. Only reason for the 4 stars was the price. A little high, but kind of expected in such a small town.
August 2019 by Dino M.
I would have given a 5 star but the service was terrible. The young lady was not friendly and my wife actually had to get up and go ask for a refills for us. The young lady only had 3 other tables than us. But the parmesan wedges were really good and the pizza was amazing.
July 2019 by Michael Bonner
Friendly, courageous staff and the food is pure WV Italian. The roasted hot peppers were fantastic. We also had a large pizza, which is served thin crust style with a scrumptious sweet tomato sauce and plenty of toppings to choose from
July 2019 by Kristina T.
Canaan Valley spot is often too busy to handle the crowds. Ordered 2 pizzas with one having more than just pepperoni but the toppings were practically nonexistent. Great food but make the drive to Davis until mgmt addresses issues at CV location.
June 2019 by Benjamin B.
A pessimal experience, deserving of a zero star rating, but that's not an option. I made a Yelp account just to complain. To begin with, the food is over-priced and shockingly low quality. I have a dairy allergy and ordered a dish that had no cheese in its description but surely enough, it arrived intrepidly piled with great amounts of cow effluvia. Upon grabbing a menu for a second look, I discovered that almost nothing had cheese in its description. It is, I take it, to be assumed that cheese is on every dish. I did not do so, and I don't think one should have to. The waitstaff was fittingly mediocre, slow, and unsympathetic. And there was no offer to remove the problematic item from the bill, despite my protestations. Do yourself a favor and avoid this place.
June 2019 by Dan Beatty
Great pizza. Eclectic building. Lemonade was just lemon juice in water. Terrible. Wine was warm and not good.
June 2019 by Erin Downard
A group of 14 is hard to please but the menu had something for everyone from 4 to 70. The staff worked together, were friendly, and very helpful. The food came out quickly and tasted amazing. Nothing like great food and great service at a local restaurant.
June 2019 by Carla Solazzo
Great food and great service.
June 2019 by Greg Bradford
Good service. Love the eclectic atmosphere. I've been here before, and the food generally has been great, but this last time (April 23rd), not so much. We had the veggie pizza, and it was like eating raw veggie on cardboard. Just a disappointment. We figured out that if we put some salt on it, it was more palatable. Definitely needs work.
June 2019 by Julie B
The pizza and homemade salad dressings are delicious. Very hot inside and close quarters. Friendly wait staff. On this visit I had Sal's pasta and it had so much garlic in it I could barely eat it and not enough olive oil dressing..... noodles were bland. Definitely a great place to eat tho. I just won't get that particular item again.
June 2019 by Dave Roberts
We stopped for lunch yesterday after a stay at Blackwater Falls State Park. Food and service was excellent. We highly recommend .
June 2019 by Danielle H.
Cool place! Wish they had more vegan/ gf options. Also was disappointed on the drink selection, but otherwise was perfect. Pizza my fb had was delicious!!
June 2019 by Katya Thresher Whitaker
Amazingly delicious FRESH pasta, salads were really really good too, and then the pizza with the thin crust cheese and basil was fresh made crust and so delicious too, it was super busy so we had a long wait but it was SO worth it!!!