January 2023 by Tammy C
The BEST pizza around! We loved it so much we went almost each day of our stay. Even the Caesar salad was fantastic! And the atmosphere is super cool! Counting down the days till we can go back!
January 2023 by Sophia N.
Disclaimer: cash only!! There is an ATM by the entrance if needed. This place was one of the few restaurants open downtown on a Monday night so my family stumbled in. They were pretty busy so we sat a table near the door and we quickly found out that the front door swings open if you don't close it properly and with every incoming customer who didn't close it all the way everyone at the front of the restaurant shot darts from their eyes. My family visited during ski season so they were pretty busy and they seemed to also be short staffed. We waited over an hour for our pizza and pasta so we were glad we ordered salads for an appetizer. There was a sign saying there is a $5 fee for whining so we made sure to wait patiently (haha). For the food, it was pretty standard American pizza. We were surprised when we ordered a Neapolitan pizza and it was basically a cheese pizza with some basil. The pasta is apparently all made in-house - a pleasant surprise.
January 2023 by raybX8983RA
First, to say the quality of the food is mediocre would be a stretch. I can’t compare the style of pizza to any type in particular because there isn’t any. The dough is not pizza dough but under stretched bread dough that is over proofed and over baked with inadequate toppings…unless you make the mistake and order the veggie pizza. Why on earth would you put that many RAW veggies on a pizza!?!? You can’t hold a slice as the bread dough does not have the structure to hold the weight. It’s due to the gallon of water from steaming the raw veggies in the oven making it a gross soggy mess. The other pizzas we got were again just over proofed/cooked bread dough with inadequate amounts of cheese/sauce/toppings to overcome the bread (not crust). Second, the service was abysmal and the treatment by the staff/manager is gross. We were there on a SLOW Friday at dinner time. There were two other tables, one when we got there and another showed up while we were there. We were a party of 7, 6 adults and 1 child. Four of us arrived first, the 2 with the child were delayed but about 15 minutes behind us in arriving due to fog. We were seated with no issue and then told we could not order until our entire party arrives. Weird, but we said ok and decided to order some apps to start then order pizza when everyone arrives. No, not allowed. No food order at all. Wow, weird, guess we’ll just start with some drinks. Nope, you can’t order ANYTHING until your full party arrives. What kind of policy is this!?!? After having to literally argue with the gross old woman who manages the place we were allowed to order some apps and drinks. It continued to get worse with the waitress ignoring us, having to ask multiple times for things like water refills and utensils, giving us the bill with our food, and the gross old lady staring at us the entire time we ate. Staring at us making the entire experience uncomfortable. After our meal all but myself and a friend got up and went outside as we were finishing our drinks. My fiend stood up from the table, with his beer in hand, and the gross old lady sprinted to the table and yelled at him saying ‘you can’t take that outside!’ Literally screamed and chastised a grown man to the point that the other two tables stopped taking and turned and looked at us. He made no attempt to move from the table and was literally taking his last sip standing and that was all. This was the last straw, he responded in a calm manner to the gross lady and said that the way she had treated us was rude and not warranted. Another waitress, not ours, mouthed to me ‘thank you’ for what my friend was doing and sticking up for himself. So, I’d recommend avoiding unless you enjoy being treated poorly by staff and crap food. That’s what it is, crap food.
January 2023 by Ray B.
I don't know what is worse, the food or the service. First, to say the quality of the food is mediocre would be a stretch. I can't compare the style of pizza to any type in particular because there isn't any. The dough is not pizza dough but under stretched bread dough that is over proofed and over baked with inadequate toppings...unless you make the mistake and order the veggie pizza. Why on earth would you put that many RAW veggies on a pizza!?!? You can't hold a slice as the bread dough does not have the structure to hold the weight. It's due to the gallon of water from steaming the raw veggies in the oven making it a gross soggy mess. The other pizzas we got were again just over proofed/cooked bread dough with inadequate amounts of cheese/sauce/toppings to overcome the bread (not crust). Second, the service was abysmal and the treatment by the staff/manager is gross. We were there on a SLOW Friday at dinner time. There were two other tables, one when we got there and another showed up while we were there. We were a party of 7, 6 adults and 1 child. Four of us arrived first, the 2 with the child were delayed but about 15 minutes behind us in arriving due to fog. We were seated with no issue and then told we could not order until our entire party arrives. Weird, but we said ok and decided to order some apps to start then order pizza when everyone arrives. No, not allowed. No food order at all. Wow, weird, guess we'll just start with some drinks. Nope, you can't order ANYTHING until your full party arrives. What kind of policy is this!?!? After having to literally argue with the gross old woman who manages the place we were allowed to order some apps and drinks. It continued to get worse with the waitress ignoring us, having to ask multiple times for things like water refills and utensils, giving us the bill with our food, and the gross old lady staring at us the entire time we ate. Staring at us making the entire experience uncomfortable. After our meal all but myself and a friend got up and went outside as we were finishing our drinks. My fiend stood up from the table, with his beer in hand, and the gross old lady sprinted to the table and yelled at him saying 'you can't take that outside!' Literally screamed and chastised a grown man to the point that the other two tables stopped taking and turned and looked at us. He made no attempt to move from the table and was literally taking his last sip standing and that was all. This was the last straw, he responded in a calm manner to the gross lady and said that the way she had treated us was rude and not warranted. Another waitress, not ours, mouthed to me 'thank you' for what my friend was doing and sticking up for himself. So, I'd recommend avoiding unless you enjoy being treated poorly by staff and crap food. That's what it is, crap food.
December 2022 by Andrej K.
Good place for a true NY style thin pizza. Crust was crisp and toppings were good. They get busy but rightfully so.
December 2022 by Myla K.
Love this restaurant. Each visit to Davis, I make time for a meal here. I love the angel hair pasta with meatballs. There is so much, I often have to take half home. The pizzas are scrumptious. You can get just about anything on it. I highly recommend Sirianni's.
December 2022 by Allen Q.
Had a lovely experience at Sirianni's, which is in the heart of Davis. We were seated immediately (granted it wasn't ski season) and the place has lots of fun decor and eclectic seating (and a pay to use jukebox if you're into that). My partner and I shared the parmesan wedges, which were good but really just cheese pizza. They were lovely with both the marinara and the ranch. We then got Johhnie's cheese pizza, which was a great blend of cheeses. It came on a lovely thin crust and the basil was a nice touch. Don't expect the best Italian you've ever had, but it's good for what it is. Don't forget it's cash only!
December 2022 by Stephanie E.
I ordered take out since it was too close to closing hour when I called and their dine-in area was closed. We ended up getting the XXX pizza and it was delicious. It brings pepperoni, ham, salami, sausage, green peppers, onions, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives and banana peppers. I want to say they do the same version but without the veggies and I definitely want to try that one next time.
December 2022 by Keith L.
Cash only! Tax evasion businesses like this make it challenging to dine out when cash isn't always on hand. You can pay their atm for cash if you want. I walked.
November 2022 by Robert W.
We decided to have a pizza Friday night and walked into the Sirianni's at 8:25. We were greeted with a look from the staff like what are you doing coming into the restaurant 35 minutes before closing. We should have walked out but we were hungry and there were no other restaurants open in Davis. This was the most uncomfortable dinner I have ever experienced. We received our pizza in about 20 minutes and ate as fast as we could to get out of that negative atmosphere. The waitress kept coming over and taking everything she could off the table to push us out the door. I could not believe how we were treated. This is not the first time I have experienced bad service from this restaurant but nothing compares to this horrible experience. I WILL NEVER RETURN TO SIRIANNI'S!
October 2022 by Diana Wright
Best pizza in the region in a delightful setting. Go early - it gets crazy busy here.Food: 5/5
October 2022 by Ladybier
This is one of the few restaurants in Davis. They are remodeling the exterior so it was difficult to find with only a tiny yellow sign in front on the median. The interior is very quaint with a few tables. The food is American style Italian. We ordered the meatball sub and a Greek salad. Both were good; the sub oven toasted, the meatballs tender and sufficient amount of sauce. The salad was the impressive part. For a small, and I mean small town, during a transitional season, the greens were crisp and the feta was half decent. Disappointed there were no pepperoncini on the salad, but hey, a little vinegar and it was delicious. The lady on the phone was pleasant and politely answered all my questions.
October 2022 by ckalliance
I was staying at the Canaan Valley resort for a conference and I always try local places when I travel somewhere. I am disabled and after the conference I was unable to do anything more than rest. I perused this menu and some coworkers were headed into town and were going to pick up an order for me. I called to inquire about their hours and if they were open, I wanted to place an order. The lady who answered the phone was so rude, I didn’t bother and if I ever happen to be in the area again, I still won’t bother. Service is literally everything.
September 2022 by L7351IWdonnac
Pizza is top notch. The angel hair pasta with meatballs and the Sal pasta dishes were absolutely horrid. The former had meatballs that were obviously days old and overcooked and marinara sauce that tasted burnt. The Sal dish had no pine nuts as advertised snd apparently the cook felt that about six cloves of rough cut garlic would be equivalent. Holy cow it was awful. I had to down a vodka and tonic with a huge slice of lime when we returned to our vacation spot to kill the garlic taste.
September 2022 by Savón M.
Spaghetti from a Italian Restaurant should be a easy basic crowd pleaser. This dish I was served was not pitiful Pasta- acceptable. nothing too bad or good Sauce- I think the sauce should accommodate the pasta and meatball this sauce did neither was more of paste then a sauce leaving the dish dry and hard to digest. Meatballs- This is my biggest let down. Super simple a lightly seasoned mix of meat cooked into a tasty ball that blends with the dish these meatballs were undercooked and mushy with poor flavor with the mixture of thin soft angel hair, paste"sauce", and a mush meatballs makes a very unpleasant mixtures of texture. Overall- Maybe someone enjoys this stuff but I would visit this establishment again nor would I Suggest it.
