Casey's at 2375 Saint Andrews Dr in Altoona, WI offers pizza delivery and pickup that many customers call the best. The pizza uses made‑from‑scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest toppings. The store also sells appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, household essentials, and groceries. A gas station is included, with pumps that provide fuel without ethanol. Customers praise the breakfast pizza as the best in town and the made‑to‑order sandwiches as good. The store is bright and clean, with easy in and easy out service. Many reviewers note the team works well, even when staff need improvement. Casey’s is a store, but it closes at 10:00.
The $2.49 fries are 'Cooked to order'- you just have to ask for them at the kitchen! Couple minutes later fresh burn my muzzle crispy potatoes are ready = delicious!
July 2026
This was my very first time trying one of your homemade pizzas. All I can say is.... OMG! THEY ARE FREAKING DELICIOUS!! Everything about it was over the top delicious!! Thank you! Keep up the great work!!
June 2026
It's clean, the staff are friendly and the pizza is made just like I remember from my childhood in South Dakota.
