-
October 2025 by taylor moore
Super cool store! My boyfriend and I built this micro fish tank. The owners son was there when we went in and he was very polite, knowledgeable and helpful.
-
October 2025 by Logan
We have been driving from Green Bay to fish cave for about a year they have an amazing selection of exotic fish to your guppies their store is very clean their fish are very healthy never had a problem with them very nice give this place a look and you will not be disappointed
-
September 2025 by Logan Wiedenfeld
Such a cool place I didn’t buy anything yet as my tank isn’t ready but they have plenty of hardscaping stone and wood as well as so many, extremely healthy looking tanks full of a variety of species. Absolutely worth the stop!!
-
August 2025 by Lizz Raymakers
Bought my betta from The Fish Cave a couple months ago. He’s been really healthy and his colors came in so vividly.
1st picture with the snail was when we first got him VS now.
His temperament is also very calm, doesn’t eat the snails or go after the corys in the tank. Could cohabitate with shrimp if we wanted to.
Would go back for my next fish
-
August 2025 by Alan
Very nice guy! Super knowledgeable about the fish as well as polite. I would recommend this store to anyone with a love for fish!
-
August 2025 by Cortney Garrett
First time visitor and will definitely be returning. Very well kept and friendly owner! I highly recommend.
-
July 2025 by Daniel Reynolds
Has aquatic life you don't see everywhere. Healthy animals and helpful staff.
-
June 2025 by Amanda Ahrndt
Fish Cave is a fish store for hobbyists, owned by a hobbyist. The quality of livestock is impeccable. There is an amazing selection, given the size of the store. The guppies are above and beyond what you can find in any other shop in the state - he's even been the first to import a strain to the US. Although this may not be important to some (but any experienced hobbyist will appreciate), he runs all of his tanks individually, preventing disease or parasites from transferring from tank to tank - this involves significantly more labor than using a system where tanks are connected, but results in much lower incidence of unhealthy fish. Fish Cave also supports the Milwaukee Aquarium Society, a local group of hobbyists.
-
May 2025 by Marybeth Gandolf
I LOVE this store. Everything about it, the prices, the fish quality, the tank cleanliness. I feel like it’s hard to find a good fish store that puts a visible effort in ensuring the health and safety of the fish. I’m glad I know I’m not only buying from a small family business but it’s ethical, the family puts passion such passion into the fish care.
-
May 2025 by Michael Caron
Very helpful with questions other pet places couldn't answer.
-
May 2025 by Kaleb Miller
First time in the store was mind blowing! They have some really beautiful fish, and very high quality fish! Overall the experience was excellent! Family owned, they are all wonderful as well! The owner is a very nice gentleman! VERY KNOWLEDGEABLE, and VERY eager to help me! My first time in the store I made several purchase’s as well! All around ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
-
May 2025 by Galaxy
Excellent variety of fish, customer service is outstanding!!!
-
April 2025 by Iseeyou
Fish all looked healthy and well cared for. Employee was nice and helpful.
-
April 2025 by Darcie Lind
Very nice store but the person working didn’t acknowledge us at all and just sat behind the register on his phone.
-
February 2025 by Neng Now
Very nice owner and well kept tanks! Good place for blackworms if you just need something small. I got 2oz, and it was more affordable than ordering online.
