The Olive Cellar in Appleton, Wisconsin, is known for offering the finest 100% Extra Virgin Olive Oils sourced globally. Their oils are cold pressed from fresh olives, complemented by an impressive selection of twelve and eighteen year aged balsamic vinegars, as well as flavored vinegars like pomegranate and blueberry. The store boasts Wisconsin's largest variety of oils and vinegars, alongside quality Italian artisan pastas, sauces, olives, wines, and spices. Customers appreciate the fantastic service, with quick shipping and helpful staff guiding them through the extensive assortment. Many agree that the olive oils and balsamics are among the best, making it worth the trip. Personalized olive oil bottles and gift options are also available.
Great selection of oil and balsamic vinegar. Can sample before purchasing and staff is very helpful.
October 2025
The Olive Cellar produces the BEST olive oil I have had. It is OUTSTANDING! They have the Best customer service and they ship immediately after placing an order. I live in Milwaukee and it is worth the price of shipping to enjoy their olive oil! Excellent!
May 2025
The Olive Cellar is the best place for high quality Olive Oil, and other gourmet products. If you’re not local, place an order online! Shipping is fast and well packaged. Support small locally owned businesses.
