-
December 2023 by Tim Martin
Disgusting. Had pizza here and no sauce whatsoever. Screwed up the order too. Fire whomever was making pizzas in the evening of Dec 21st.
-
December 2023 by Tamarra Taylor
If I could give the employees of the Baraboo location 10 stars I would! I go there a lot because the pizza is absolutely the best, and I have only had excellent experiences talking w the staff! Casey’s is a lucky company to have the workers they have in Baraboo because the workers are absolutely amazing!
-
October 2023 by Allen Cohn
Its just a gas station with outdated cc machines at the pump
-
September 2023 by Alexa
My pizza was delivered cold on top of it being delayed. Not even warm, just cold.
-
August 2023 by Kim Krajecki Griffin
Delicious pizza ! They also have thin crust and gluten free crust! Good place to work for.....they do care about their employees. Love their Casey's brand chips and Cheese puffs...the jalapeno ones are bomb!
-
November 2022 by JoBeara
I was very surprised at how delicious the pizza was from a convenience store! Will definitely be back to try different kinds of pizza. They have everything you would need if in a hurry. Only negative problem is they close very early now (I'm sure there is a good reason). Staff is always friendly!
-
August 2022 by DP
As an employee at another Casey's they are doing a great job! Stopped on my way to the Madison Zoo and they where freindly and welcoming!
-
July 2022 by Rick Bullis
Always a great store with good prices
-
June 2022 by Sara R Parsons
Great food & quality service.
-
February 2022 by Graysin Wolfe
Very disappointed in the management at this location and the kitchen staff. Not only is the quality horrendous compared to 7 years ago at this exact same location. But the staff in the kitchen actively tries to get you not to order food... because they're just too busy!?!? You sell food you want to be busy why would you actively try to get people to not order food on a Friday or Saturday night but you don't have to worry I won't be ordering any more food from here
-
December 2021 by Office Staff
Absolutely wonderful! My 1st time having their pizza and it is so good! And the ladies here are so sweet!
-
February 2021 by MagicHaxGames
Would rate zero stars if I couldStaff was not wearing masks and were coughing within my vicinity
-
January 2021 by Ashton Faul
BEST pizza in town! Friendly staff as well!
-
January 2021 by Janette Wilson
Great customer service clean
-
December 2020 by Keri-jo McCarron
Delicious pizza's to order, easy pick up, friendly staff