Old Rittenhouse Inn is a beautiful old mansion located in Bayfield, offering a perfect blend of old-world charm and modern comfort. Guests have praised the amazing food at the restaurant and the delicious breakfast included with their stay. The views of Lake Superior from the rooms add to the serene atmosphere. The cozy and well-furnished rooms, such as the Moroccan Suite, provide a comfortable retreat, reminiscent of childhood memories for some visitors. The staff is noted for being friendly and courteous, creating a welcoming environment. While the location is peaceful and beautiful, some guests mention that the stairs may be challenging for those with knee issues. Overall, Old Rittenhouse Inn is highly recommended for its stunning setting, excellent service, and delightful dining options, making it a sought-after destination for return visits.
If you’re looking for a top tier meal and fantastic service in Bayfield, the Old Rittenhouse Inn is the spot! Briana is a fantastic server!
August 2026
Had an amazing dinner at the Inn. The Whitefish soup and speciality entree were delicious. Our server Jack was gregarious and a delight
July 2026
I stayed here with my boyfriend (now fiance) and this place was one of the best parts of our stay. The room was amazing, the dinner and service were also outstanding. Also, the location is really great, every fun thing was walkable.
