-
October 2023 by Tom Fabjance
Nice little spot. Clean and nicely remodeled. Old fisherman bar. One of Bayfield’s few taverns. Let’s keep it alive! Darts, pool table and regional craft beer on tap.
-
October 2023 by Sonya Knueppel
Had a few drinks with my fellow colleagues and the service was great. Atmosphere was awesome with the excitement of watching the packer game. The bartender was awesome and the locals were welcoming.
-
August 2023 by Patrick Shaw
Quaint little bar with nice crafts on tap!
-
December 2022 by Brad “Butch” Colburn
The only place open at 9:30 on a Thursday night, at least in downtown walking distance. We each had a drink after our concert. Nice noisy younger crowd.
-
October 2022 by John Hahn
Great place free pool on Tuesday.
-
October 2022 by steve servais
Small but nice and clean. Mix drinks not the best but will do in a pinch.
-
August 2022 by Yana Nazarenka
Came to The Creamery Bar & apparently customer service ends at 10pm in this town, bartenders were rude the moment I walked in. They have a pool table so I guess that’s a plus. They just seem so unhappy. Last call was abruptly at 12pm with a full bar—LITERALLY PACKED. I asked for a lemon with my drink that I was getting with my drinks throughout the night & lemons were unavailable at last call because they had “already been put away” I paid to play music & they couldn’t play the music due to closing, when clearly at least 25 people were still hanging out and wanting to drink. After I received my drink we were kicked out to the porch & it was loud & crowded. Wouldn’t recommend coming to this place. There were more than 20 people who got “kicked out” at 12:30. Ridiculous compared to years past. The bartenders were mean the entire night. Didn’t seem interested or mildly invested in the business they work for. Seemed like they were more interested in just going home. Bummer for tourists and locals wanting to have a fun night on a Friday. So sad for a used to be awesome bar.
-
August 2022 by Christopher Soulier
It's really annoying when you work locally for over 8 hours almost every day and just want to get a few drinks to decompress and you really can't do that. Why are the bartender's doing last call at midnight on a busy Friday night? Especially being the only bar open in a 15 mile radius. I really didn't wanna post this review but it's been going on for weeks. It's unfortunate to see how far downhill this bar has gone within a year.
-
August 2022 by Scott Payne
A great place for a drink and bar food. Friendly staff, clean, and fun patrons. A must stop if you want to meet locals.
-
August 2022 by skillert69
Nice local bar! Kylie was a great bartender!
-
July 2022 by Brad Colburn
The only place open at 9:30 on a Thursday night, at least in downtown walking distance. We each had a drink after our concert. Nice noisy younger crowd.
-
December 2021 by Amber Heetel
Loved my time there and will definitely be back!
-
December 2021 by Jessica Brogley
What a fun vibe to this bar. I appreciate the historical term and ample seating.
-
October 2021 by Tom Mullen
Great place to watch the Packers! Pizza was great. Good beer selection with Midwest craft beers on tap or your favorite domestics from cans and bottles.
-
September 2021 by Benjamin Fink
Might have been ok, hard to say. We walked in on an late Sunday afternoon and there was no bartender or any visible employees. The other patrons stared at us as we walked in and we didn't feel like we were welcome. I suspect this might be a bar for the locals and not so much for tourists. We left and went Mortys around the corner. They were awesome.
