-
February 2024 by richard sayles
Sent in an online order the order was massively messed up when asked to be fixed they refused to fix said that they could make the other pizza but would have to pay for it will never order food or shop at this Casey’s anymore will also let my friends and family know how the management and store is ran. If I could give a lower review I would
-
February 2024 by Kaylee
Tia was EXCEPTIONAL! She was very patient with me and my mother and helped us through the issue we were having! She deserves a raise! Thank you
-
January 2024 by Idaliah Appel
Vegetarian options: They have a veggie pizza optionParking: You can park up front, on the right side of the store and at/by the gas pumpsWheelchair accessibility: On both ends of the side walk in the front of the store are wheel chair accessible
-
January 2024 by Melissa Owens
Taco pizza and breakfast pizzas are the best !
-
September 2023 by John Smith
I won't be going back here for my lunch break ever! I went in for a slice of pizza and it is paper-thin and full of grease. The lady told me a medium soda and a slice of pizza is $4 And I ended up paying way more than that and she knew that was what I wanted and didn't even bother telling me I had the wrong cup size! Apparently there is no small cup, it goes medium, large, and extra large I picked the middle cup cause usually that's pretty much always a medium!
-
September 2023 by melissa A
Was here tonight around 8 PM. The two young ladies working at the front counter. Were eating behind the counter smacking away. On their phones. There have been other times they will be on their phones face timing and tell you to wait. Very poor customer service.
-
October 2022 by jdthatsme
The new breakfast burritos are awesome but call ahead and order them
-
July 2022 by Jim N
No online ordering. Only location in 100 miles where this is the case. Big yikes.
-
May 2022 by Owen Salzwedel
The Casey’s in beaver dam wi is horrible . Terrible service and never any slices of pizza out Morning or lunch absolutely ridiculous . Just awful ?
-
April 2022 by Luke Tischler
I Still Miss The Video Reel but Casey's is still The BEST place in town to get gas.Always super-friendly clerks& My car gets Way Better gas mileage for the money on Casey's Non-Ethanol and runs smoother than any other gas around.Period.
-
March 2022 by Draya Buechel
Ordered a barbecue beef speciality pizza, instead of telling me they didn’t have that on their menu (obviously someone new not knowing it used to be a specialty pizza) the cook decided to just change one of their pizzas to accommodate what she thought I wanted and didn’t tell me that’s what she was doing. Ended up with me paying for a disgusting pizza that I did not want. Thanks for the communication!
-
February 2022 by Jessica S.
I stop in here a couple times a week. Great variety of food and snacks. Staff is rarely friendly, but I'm in there at 6:30am. I'm not a morning person either.
-
January 2022 by Stu Sterrenberg
This is the rating for Management. The staff on Saturday night did their best despite being overwhelmed with orders (pizza was legit). Need to hire mor staff but going to be tough at $12/hr.
-
November 2021 by Jennifer Wright
If today was their best day I'll never step foot in there again. Either hire more staff or replace what is there. Stood at the pizza counter for 15 minutes and never acknowledged. The cashier at the front wasn't any more helpful. We walked out and went to your competitors. If you work in Customer service you need to have polite and attentive workers. Greatly disappointed
-
September 2021 by Jared Niewoehner
Rating on my experience today only. Ordered the breakfast pizza which we’ve had here and at several other Casey’s store before. Usually it’s thick crust and loaded with ingredients and cheese. Today it was almost a thin crust and it seemed like they scraped the bottom of the barrel for every ingredient, it was dry with hardly any sauce; they were extremely stingy on cheese, and the crust seemed much thinner than usual. The egg was also over cooked and slightly burnt. Hopefully just a one time issue, but it was very disappointing compared to the usual breakfast pizza .
