Decatur Dairy is a popular cheese shop known for its delicious cheese and friendly service. Visitors often drive long distances, sometimes up to 124 miles round trip, just to enjoy their tasty grilled cheese sandwiches, which are considered the best by many. The shop is busy and smaller than expected, with a line of customers helped by a friendly staff, including young ladies like Meghan who quickly prepare their favorite sandwiches and cheese selections. The prices are reasonable, with sandwiches costing around $5, and customers frequently express that the experience is worth the effort, rating it five stars. Besides cheese, they also make ice cream, which many find excellent and worth trying in waffle cones. The shop offers a wide variety of cheese flavors, including cheese curds like Muenster and unique options with mold or holes, and flavors such as green olives. Visitors enjoy tasting and purchasing cheese, especially during regular visits, and appreciate the helpful staff. Overall, Decatur Dairy provides a fun, flavorful, and friendly experience for cheese lovers.
I go out of my way to get my cheese from here when Iām in the area. Great fresh cheese and cheese curds, samples are available as well. Plus they have a small seating area for a quick sandwich. Absolutely a quintessential Wisconsin Dairy, making great Cheese, made local, made fresh, and made in America the way it should... read full comment
February 2026
Great cheese at a good price. Their grilled cheese was awesome š
January 2026
Great cheese!! My favorite is the Stettlers Swiss and their grilled cheese sandwich.
