Greater Milwaukee Coin & Jewelry is an honest and fair shop that pays the best prices. Customers report fast, painless transactions and often receive a higher return than expected. The staff is knowledgeable, professional, kind, and welcoming, taking time to listen and offer helpful pointers. Many have had positive experiences selling items like silver, gold, coins, and jewelry, as well as making purchases. The shop is considered the best around, leading customers to prefer it over online options and to definitely return. The Brookfield location is noted, with a reminder of temporary Wednesday and Friday closures.