Old Country Cheese is a must stop in the Cashton area, known as the best place for cheese curds. It offers warm, fresh curds, including plain, deep fried, and flavors like taco, pizza, and dill. The shop also provides a wide variety of other cheeses, Amish made goods, meats, ice cream, jams, butter, and cookbooks. Beautiful handmade wood items like cutting boards are available. The drive out is beautiful and the employees are friendly and helpful. It is a nice little shop with a wonderful selection, and visitors are never disappointed.
Michael was friendly and helpful with suggestions on best cheese curds!
October 2025
Nice stop for a variety of cheeses, including fresh regular and flavored curd as well as deep fried curd. They sell a variety of Amish made goods and also serve ice cream.
October 2025
Some cool products. Good prices. They have great big butter roll pacakges. Worth a visit to the Amish country.
