Candy Stores in Eagle River, WI

“The Best Candy and Ice Cream Store in Eagle River, WI

If you’re anywhere near Eagle River, do yourself a favor and make The Country Store your first stop. This charming local treasure is hands-down one of the best places to visit in the Northwoods—especially if you love homemade fudge, ice cream, and chocolatey treats that are out of this world!

Let’s start with the fudge: it’s made fresh in-house, and it’s truly the best homemade fudge in the Northwoods. Rich, creamy, and available in a mouthwatering variety of flavors, it’s impossible to leave without picking up a slice (or three). Their chocolate turtles and other handmade confections are equally irresistible—perfect for gifting or indulging right on the spot.

The ice cream selection is another reason to stop by—especially with kids in tow. With classic and seasonal flavors served in generous scoops, it’s the perfect treat on a warm day or after a day of exploring Eagle River. My kids always ask to stop here, and it’s become a fun tradition for our family!

Beyond the sweets, The Country Store offers a delightful mix of locally made gifts, unique home décor, Wisconsin souvenirs, and gourmet goodies.

Whether you’re a tourist passing through or a local who hasn’t stopped in for a while, this place is a true gem. Treat yourself—you won’t regret it!”

“This is honestly one of my favorite chocolate shops I've ever been to throughout the USA and I don't say that lightly. A shop like this in a tourist town is almost guaranteed to be overpriced but IMO the prices here are reasonable. Quality is great and the staff are very friendly and efficient.”

“I’m thrilled with my experience ordering from this shop! Rebecca assisted me with an online order and was extremely helpful, kind, courteous and professional from start to finish. She went above and beyond to not only resolve an issue (shipping problem, no fault of the store’s) but think outside of the box and save the day. I’m not local, but would definitely recommend coming here. Thank you!”