-
April 2024 by Bill R.
Went for Comedy night dinner show. Wasn't sure what to expect. Buffet style meal - German theme with good selection of authentic dishes. I particularly liked the pot roast with vegetables. Also had chicken, fish and sausage. Sides were just like grandma makes. There was plenty to eat. And, we did. Dessert was German Chocolate cake. The comedians did about a 90 minute show. It was interactive so the closer you sat to the stage then more fun you had. Lots of kibitzing and nothing off color. We had fun. Overall the food was fine. Nothing to rave about. Wished the dinner plates had been warmed. Good hot food on very cold plates didn't sit well with me. The show was mid range. No guy busting laughing but plenty of chuckles and a lot of self depreciation. We would do it again. Learned that they have other theme nights, so check that out before you go.
-
March 2024 by Nancy Kuhlmey
First time here and enjoy myself with my granddaughter. Yes hope to come back again in the future. Thank you so much love it.
-
March 2024 by Bryon Shea
The staff is incredibly kind and attentive. Asher and Dianna behind the bar are hard working and very kind. The hostess and other server were smiling and hardworking.The Carolina Chicken Sandwich had a nice flavor, was hot and tasted fresh. Nice job, Carrington!
-
January 2024 by Jolina Metoxen
We always have the best experience at the Carrington!
-
December 2023 by Coleen Salome
Beautiful view of the lake and forest from the restaurant. Food is good and well presented. Personnel does a great job!
-
December 2023 by Brian F.
My sister picked this place after a small family funeral. We were early, and they were very accommodating! We sat at the perfect table by the fireplace. The view is spectacular, but we knew that because we hail from Door County. Very pleasant service, the food outstanding. Saw my favorite Au poirve on the menu, and it was delicious. Everyone enjoyed everything from the drinks to dessert. Thank you, Carrington, for a great "early" evening! We will be back!
-
November 2023 by Soothing Souls
My large family vacations every year at the resort. We always eat at the restaurant and the food is fabulous.
-
October 2023 by Rich McGee
Pricey. The server was super sweet. However the bar service was poor. The food was good though the NY strip was mostly fat. I recommend the walleye piccata.
-
October 2023 by michelle gasparek
We were really looking forward to dining there. The atmosphere was nice. The service, “Ken” was amazingly bad. Never asked if we wanted water, another drink, dessert,etc. Didn’t bring condiments we had asked for repeatedly, was truly horrible. We were in a great mood, he really didn’t meet our needs. We had reservations for the next night, were excited about the next night, but canceled our reservations based solely on the horrible service on the previous night. Wouldn’t go again.
-
September 2023 by Darin Nederhoff
I’ve been coming here since it opened. Great relaxed atmosphere and great view. Great place to have dinner and a drink to take in a sunset.Wheelchair accessibility: Easy drive up drop off and nearby handicapped parking
-
September 2023 by D N
Some of the food was good and some was really bad. Prime rib was good. Fish was over cooked and scallop potatos were bland and dry. The comedy show was terrible. The only positive was a staff member that sang prior to the two comedians. The show was incredibly hard to sit through and people just wanted it to be over.
-
September 2023 by Wendy Gaar
If you plan to have curry as a specialty it would be a good idea if the "chef" has tasted curry before. No seasoning, bland, not good. Also the turkey in a hot brown should be real turkey not lunch meat. Very disappointing. Server appeared not thrilled to be there, doing the absolute minimum she had to do. Again very disappointing.
-
September 2023 by Bob Z.
Good new menu. Wife had Chili Colorado and me Hot Brown. Both unique and tasty dinners reasonably priced. Good service. Nice time.
-
September 2023 by tgoest33
The Carrington is a very relaxed and friendly restaurant. Ratings for: Staff: Excellent, very personable, knowledgeable; we had a lovely time talking with our waitress who was from Croatia. It made our time there very casual and relaxed. I cannot remember her name but she was lovely!! Food: Excellent!!! My husband had the Shrimp Scampi and he commented about the sauce and the fact that the tails were taken off the shrimp. I ordered the special which was Scallops in a pesto sauce with fettuccine. The sauce was incredible!! A very creamy pesto sauce that I never would have thought to combine!! View: We sat inside as I cannot stand bees buzzing about if I’m outside! But their outside seating was very scenic. Our view from inside was lovely with a view of the lake. Pricing: It’s a bit pricey, but we knew that going in: but we went during happy hour (4-5pm). I’m a wine drinker so I truly enjoyed knowing any wine I wanted was $2.00 off for happy hour! My husband enjoyed a couple of the amber ales, from a local brewery. Overall: Quiet atmosphere and nice staff! Would definitely go back!!! Hope you give it a try!!
-
September 2023 by Watertown_Traveler
Decided to treat ourselves to prime rib . We were not disappointed. It was very flavorful and melt in your mouth. Also had the French onion pountine. Also, very good. Our server, Lana was friendly and courteous. All of the staff were friendly.
