-
February 2024 by Sheila O.
Every time I have eaten or have ordered take out at Elroy Eatery, the food and service is incredible. The portions are larger than I've experienced at previous restaurants. I recommend this establishment to those looking for a fantastic meal at a reasonable price. They truly believe in quality!!!!
-
February 2024 by Donna Field
I had their blackened hamburger and it was great! Their pizza is also amazing. The staff was great.
-
January 2024 by Jamie Berg
Phenomenal breakfast food and the best customer service! Very impressed with the quantity and quality of the food at a very reasonable price. They go above and beyond to make sure you have what you need and want for your food order! Highly recommend!
-
January 2024 by Michael Royce
Great fish on Friday night, small diner atmosphere. Will be going back .
-
December 2023 by Donna Stanfield
Well went to try what was supposed to be voted "best fish fry*, disappointed to say the least. Must say it was just cod but I don't think we'll be back, service was just ok they were really packed and busy, so why I give 3 stars!!! Daughter had a burger and had no lettuce, tomato, onion or mayo had to ask for a little,
-
December 2023 by Megan S.
DON'T EAT AT ELROY EATERY! Breakfast is my favorite meal and for 35 years I have been doing breakfast at my local establishments where I share more than just breakfast... I share fellowship with my neighbors and even people I just met. It truly makes me feel proud to be apart of these gatherings and it's a great way to start my day until it wasn't ... my last outing to Elroy Eatery was nothing but a nightmare. In fact the owner asked me to leave without my breakfast. You see a great friend of mine and I stopped to patronize their establishment and we were served rotten ranch dressing, it was actually yellow, and my food was way undercooked. We shared with them the rotten ranch dressing in which we passed on and I asked them to please cook my sausage all the way through. The staff was not apologetic nor did they remove the meal from our bill, nor did they offer to replace it... in fact I was so lucky that I got to eat right next to the rotten ranch dressing. I tried to just chalk it up to a bad day and I decided I would give them another shot and I stopped with my daughter... we were immediately asked about the ranch dressing and the server admitted it was bad and said they had to throw it out. She also explained that another patron was spreading rumors about it, not me, ANOTHER patron. Our meal was okay, I left a very hefty tip for the server and went on my way. A few days later, I returned to the Elroy Eatery to have my morning breakfast and the owner asked me to leave and said I WILL NOT SERVE YOU because she was not happy about me telling them about the less than stellar food they were serving. I have overlooked the many times they have misprepared my food, the many times my food has been cold, and/or the constant harassment from their cook telling me I shouldn't be running my mouth. I had also heard from a couple patrons about how undercooked their fish was. I was completely appalled by their actions and they have yet to apologize for the issues with their food andor to offer me a refund, they have not apologized for the embarrassment of being kicked out in front of all the patrons, or the shear disrespect of my hard working money that I give to them for a service.
-
October 2023 by Larry Glick
Good service, good food, great atmosphere!
-
October 2023 by Karen F.
Great breakfast there yesterday! Husband's biscuits and gravy excellent...huge portions!
-
October 2023 by Leonard Wohlgemuth
I've only had the fish and pizza, both were great ?
-
October 2023 by K Kristi B.
Excellent Food, atmosphere, clean and cozy and so many foods on the Menu. Excellent Friday Fish Fries, Excellent Pizza.A MUST GOBTO EATERY. April Excellent Attentive Waitress.Thank You Can't wait to go back.
-
October 2023 by Alison Brown
Always great food and friendly service.
-
October 2023 by Jessica Lauer
Definitely recommend stopping by this place if you’re ever in the area!We were in town visiting family for the week so we ended up going to the Eatery a few times which allowed us the opportunity to try out several of their dishes!-Biscuits and gravy-Pizza-Onion Rings-Fried Pickles-Smoked Ribs with homemade baked beans and fries-Chocolate Chip pancakes-Prime Rib Breakfast SkilletAll of the food was delicious, it arrived quickly and fresh.The staff was very friendly and on top of their game making sure drinks stayed filled and caring for a restaurant full with other customers.The owners even came out from the kitchen from time to time to interact with their customers which was great to see!The restaurant and bathrooms were very clean which is a huge point in my book!
-
October 2023 by demodeakin
Awesome stop for some great Friday Fish Fry in a quaint setting.It's a bit of a drive, but a nice scenic one to get here and slow it down a bit.
-
October 2023 by twyla graewin
We have ordered pizzas about 3 times now and twice the pizzas were not ready when we were told they would be. Very disappointing that when we order and ask for pick up at a certain time and you go in to pick it up it's not even been put in the oven yet so you have to wait another 20 mins.
-
October 2023 by Khris Miller
Great food! Clean. Pleasant atmosphere. Great staff and owners.
