Carr Valley Cheese, located in Fennimore, is renowned for being one of the most award-winning cheese companies in the world, offering over 100 varieties of Wisconsin cheese. Visitors can enjoy a delightful selection of specialty gifts and local accompaniments alongside the famous squeaky fresh cheese curds. The store is praised for its incredible sharp cheddar and unique flavors like horseradish cheddar, which customers recommend trying. Many cherish the tradition of visiting Carr Valley Cheese, often taking pictures with the giant mouse while sampling delicious cheeses and enjoying ice cream. The friendly and knowledgeable staff are always ready to help customers find the perfect cheese for recipes, cheeseboards, or gifts. Although some visitors wish they lived closer, they express excitement about returning for the best cheese curds in Wisconsin and exploring the charming gift shop. Carr Valley Cheese promises a memorable experience for all cheese lovers.
I can only eat sheeps milk cheese. This is the place that makes it. Cute tiny little shop off the creamery. The two little ladies there were absolutely amazing!!! Fun to talk with.
October 2025
Staff are always cheerful, cheese selections are fantastic 😋
September 2025
Best place around for fresh curd. Clerk was knowledgeable and friendly.
