Hours may fluctuate. For detailed hours of operation, please contact the store directly.
About The Fenway House Hotel
The Fenway House Hotel offers a charming and historic experience with modern comforts. Built in 1918, the hotel has been updated to retain its nostalgic feel while providing guests with a comfortable stay. The rooms are unique and well-equipped, featuring amenities such as mini fridges, microwaves, coffee makers, and air conditioning, making guests feel at home. Many reviews highlight the comfort of the beds, the cozy atmosphere, and the beautiful decor. Guests also appreciate thoughtful touches like coffee setups and easy access to ice machines and nearby cafes and restaurants. The hotel stands out for its simple and secure check-in process, where guests receive a door code in advance, and rooms are ready upon arrival. The staff, including owners and managers, are described as friendly, professional, and accommodating, often going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay. The location is convenient for various activities, including attending local events or visiting family nearby, and offers scenic drives, such as the route to UW Platteville, with sights like Amish buggies. Overall, The Fenway House Hotel is praised for its historical charm, cleanliness, and excellent service. It provides a cozy, welcoming atmosphere at a good value, making it a highly recommended place for travelers seeking a unique and comfortable stay in a friendly town.
Very charming building, old but lots of character. A hidden gem that Fennimore is lucky to have!
October 2025
Great old hotel right in the middle of downtown Fenimore
September 2025
We had the opportunity to stay in room 101 for a 1 night stay. Room was lovely. The owner Sue was very pleasant and knowledgeable, she gave us a tour of the historic building.
