-
April 2024 by John B.
We were super disappointed to discover that Bayside doesn't offer Mezcal at the bar. Mind-boggling! It wasn't like we were asking for Hesperidina, Becherovka, or some other obscure liqueur. Just a simple Mezcal Margarita.
-
April 2024 by John Hickey
Fun place, really good food, and friendly staff! Highly recommended ??
-
April 2024 by Giovanni Canales
The food was amazing, the steak sandwich and the fish patties were so good. Service was great and fast, the location and vibe of the place was relaxed, perfect way to end a bike ride.
-
April 2024 by James Charmelo
When White Gull Inn turned my girlfriend and me away at 1 pm. on Easter because we didn't have unmentioned, required reservations, we headed to BaySide Tavern. We were here a couple years ago, and the brat burgers were excellent then! I enjoyed that monster of a burger, and my girlfriend loved the whitefish cakes! The atmosphere and people were friendly, with a local pastor coming in and engaging with the staff and patrons, giving this establishment a real hometown feel! Even as out-of-towners, we felt welcomed and at home!
-
April 2024 by Jean Yves Niedzwiecki
Bayside, unarguabley, has some of the best tasting burgers in Door County. Juicie, and perfectly cooked? you will definitely enjoy the experience.
-
April 2024 by Judy Pearson
Great experience overall!
-
April 2024 by SE Hughes
Bartenders are flippant. Bloody Mary is not good. I want to like this place more. Owners should make a few changes to hit 5 star.
-
April 2024 by Joseph Wouters
Been coming here for 30 years - tonight the worst - young staff more concerned with chit chatting behind bar than filling empty glasses - then they turn NCAA tournament to Ultimate fighting because 2 bartenders needed to watch / and customers had to request the tournament to be turned back on- and then the 2 bartenders continued to watch the one TV that UFC was turned on instead of tending to there customers
-
April 2024 by Kevin Butler
Excellent perch fry on Fridays. An institution in Fish Creek for a reason. Good beer list, as well.
-
March 2024 by William Urfer
And here is a Charming little bar with good food, people, decorations and fast
-
March 2024 by Ann A
Ordered Philly cheese steak and seafood soup. There were a couple thin slices of steak in my sandwich, super dry, no onion, raw green peppers. The sandwich was 75% mushrooms, and they charge $18 for the sandwich. The soup had a weird sweet flavor. It’s way overpriced for bar food that doesn’t taste good.
-
March 2024 by Lilly B.
We just happened to stop by Bayside on our road trip and boy were we not disappointed! We were greeted with friendly faces like Ana's. She took such great care of me and my stir crazy kiddos, if I am ever in Wisconsin again I will be stopping by again not only for the food but to see Ana again!
-
March 2024 by Maggie
Service was horrendous and it wasn’t busy at all. Plenty of staff were there and we were completely ignored after our water was brought to us. Patrons that came in after us were helped and we were ignored. Ended up leaving after waiting 20 minutes to order food. Extremely disappointing.PS - Read the rest of the 1 star reviews, owners! The 1 star issue seems to stem from your staff (or at least one waitress in particular..)
-
February 2024 by michele weissinger
We had a wonderful lunch of Philly cheese steak and chili. Both were delicious. The service was the best we have had in a long time. The atmosphere was perfect on a cold winter
-
February 2024 by Dan Kunda
The chili is "Kickass". Plenty to eat. Not crowded when we went 1900 (7p.m.) Lot's of parking.
