-
December 2023 by Kristin D
If you like pie, you need to come here! The Pie Lady is passionate about what she does, and will make sure you leave with something you like, that you will have time to bake to perfection. She discouraged us from getting a whole pie, because we weren’t sure we would be home long enough that evening to bake it properly, suggesting instead several of the small individual pies, and they did indeed take a long time to bake, so we enjoyed them for breakfast - so delicious! They encourage you to call, but even had several varieties of gluten free pie in stock.Dietary restrictions: They had several kinds of whole and small individual gluten free pies available frozen when we stopped in, but offer a larger selection if you call ahead of time.
-
December 2023 by SFaye Kachikis
Small selection since we got there later in the day. Bakery is pricey. Crumble on top of pies was good, but the crust was tough. Cute shop.Parking: sufficient number of spots
-
December 2023 by JL NotHere
EDITAt least the owners response confirms they will eves drop and make people unwelcome. Even having no clue on context of a conversation, expect explosive unhinged attacks.I was just disgusted by how I was treated. My friend and I were having a private conversation the owner found issue with.Its just gross behavior from this place.
-
October 2023 by Gary M.
Great Cherry Pies!!! Super friendly service. Order a day in advance for a whole pie! Worth the stop!
-
October 2023 by Ioana Savos
Amazing
-
October 2023 by Teresa
I am a bit of a pie snob and this was one of the best pieces of pie I have ever had! We tried the cherry crumble pie (with homemade vanilla gelato) and the cherry apple pie (with fresh whipped cream) and they were both so good. Fresh, flavorful, not overly sweet, and not even remotely artificial. You can tell they were homemade with fresh ingredients. I would come back here again and again! This is a must-stop when visiting door county.
-
October 2023 by Brenda B
Great pies, you must visit when you go to Door county
-
October 2023 by Barb Sharbuno
Best cherry pie in Door County. 3 lbs of cherries in each pie. Crispy light flakey pie crust. Staff are friendly and know their business. Will definitely be a repeat customer.
-
October 2023 by Jacob Quigley
Very very overpriced. Also if you want a full size pie...you hafta call a day beforehand. Sweetie pies was really great up until about 6 months ago! Don't bother. Go to bea's homemade products instead. Or seaquist.
-
September 2023 by Barb S.
Spent time in Fish Creek and decided to try Sweetie Pies cherry pie. It was delicious and I ordered an apple pie to treat my friends in Milwaukee.We had it this afternoon and everyone loved the pie. Nice Cinnamon flavor, great tasting apples and crust.When there met Chris and staff. Everyone was so nice and friendly. I will be ordering for Thanksgiving. Thank you for making our Sunday afternoon special.
-
September 2023 by Anne L.
Was in the area with my mom to explore Door County. Mom wanted a piece of cherry pie and a cup of coffee. We stopped at Sweetie pies. I had a slice of pecan pie. Mom had a slice of cherry.My pecan pie was delicious. Mom said her cherry pie was the best she's ever had!Stop by sweetie pie and get a slice!
-
September 2023 by John F.
A pie shop is Door County... of course! Yes, you can get pies at lots of places in this tourist destination. But you will not get the assortment of choices that this place has. Plus they are really great! Sweetly Pies has a chalk board type menu that goes up every morning and as the day goes on the choices start to dwindle.... So come early! You can pre-order. Which is a great idea. They will hold your pie for you! I think they have 3 sizes to choice from, from individual slices to full pies to take home. The business is kind of small, but it's pretty cute. Think a little cottage in the woods (like Hansel and Gretel without the witch). If you get a slice, you can sit on the porch and eat. Prefect pastime in the summer sun.
-
September 2023 by travelbug60097
When we came to Sweetie Pies last year, we arrived an hour before they closed, and most of the pies were gone. This year we went and ordered pies to pick up on our way out of town. The gal taking our order was super friendly and helpful, as was the woman who was there when we picked up our pies. We got a cherry for friends, and a cherry crumble for us. It was hands down the best cherry pie I’ve ever tasted - hubby agrees! We will definitely return on our next visit to Door County, so that we can try some of the other tempting varieties of pie!
-
August 2023 by Jess Law
We tried apple, pumpkin, pecan, and chocolate chess pie - all of them were good but pumpkin was my favorite. I’d love to go back again and try more of the many pies they make! Get there early in the day to have the most options. If you want a whole pie, make sure you call a day or more in advance to make a reservation, otherwise it’s by the slice.
-
August 2023 by Joshua Shirley
I'm just going to quick add to the positive reviews here...Stop in, it's a nice setting, we happened in on a Sunday with live music.Those things were just a bonus to what the pie had already given us. We tried a few varieties with the apple crumble being by far the favorite. Really isn't much more to say, stop in for a slice, I'm sure you won't be disappointed.
