-
April 2024 by David M
Having traveled the world and experienced all manner of foods, this was without doubts, one of if not truly the very best pizza ever. It’s taste was only matched by the genuine kindest group of individuals one could hope for.
-
April 2024 by Max Riley
This Pizza is the best I’ve ever had. Small but nice atmosphere with friendly employees. Now for the bad, and reasons for the one star review. For carry out they sneak in a “Carry out fee” for each item you buy!! Who does this when our economy is terrible. Then to add insult to injury they charge you for using a credit card. I think at $30 per pizza they would be able to absorb those extra fees to keep the customer happy.Update to my initial review. No where on their website does it mention a “Carry Out Fee” or credit card “Surcharge Fee” that to me are hidden charges that need to be posted before making a purchase.
-
April 2024 by Sapphireartist0928
Top-notch pizza!! Service was so friendly, offered me a seat while I looked at the menu and waited for my takeout order. You can tell the dough and sauce are all fresh and homemade. None of that greasy, flavorless pizza you get from the big chains. The pizza sauce just pops. Was very close to returning the next day just to buy one of the jars of sauce they sell. Missed opportunity on my part! We'll be back again!
-
April 2024 by Adam
The staff was amazing, the food was tasty, and I can't recommend the pizza enough!!
-
April 2024 by M D
Really good wood fired pizza
-
March 2024 by Paige Redlin
Just visited door county and wild tomato in fish bay for the first time this weekend! Wild tomato was delicious, the restaurant is self is small but it is so cute and definitely worth trying!
-
March 2024 by Cassandra Valentino
The pizza is amazing!!! Ordered margarita pizza and was able to eat whole large with my son. We also ordered cheese curds and they almost had me sick. Soooooooo greasy I couldn’t get past the second one. This place is small as well. Water was foggy and didn’t want to try to drink
-
February 2024 by Tessa Olson
This was my second time at a Wild Tomato and my first time at this location. I personally think the pizza is overpriced and I definitely recommend the location in Sister's Bay over this one. That one is much bigger and a more fun atmosphere. This location would be nice during summer to sit outside, but I would still drive the 15 minutes more north to go to the other location.
-
February 2024 by Joshua Leick
Really great food and atmosphere with a reasonable price. Could be a little bit bigger but great place.
-
February 2024 by Brittany Schewe
Delicious!!
-
February 2024 by Jeff H.
Had my family here in Fish Creek for dinner. There was a wait but it was a beautiful winter evening and wasn't to cold outside while we waited. The inside seating is small thus the wait. The pizzas were excellent! We had four different kinds. The staff were friendly and attentive and we had a good time.
-
January 2024 by Luke Cahak
Great food! Excellent service. I would recommend stopping in.
-
January 2024 by Cynthia Ortiz
Pizza was delicious, made with fresh ingredients and the service was excellent!
-
December 2023 by Eric Spata
We have visited door county for Christmas every year for 10 years and always start our trip with wild tomato. Called tonight at 7:30 and sat on hold for 20 minutes. Then when someone answered i asked to place an order for takeout and their response was that they closed soon. So I clarified by asking if we could still order. She then repeated herself to say they closed soon. So i asked if they lock the doors at 8 or stop serving customers at 8. She then pretended the connection was bad and hung up. I guess that means they lock the doors at 8 and stop serving customers at 7:30. Good thing to know when you plan your dinner.
-
December 2023 by Bonnie C.
Had looked forward to stopping in for lunch past few drives by. That's done. Service was best part of experience - quick and attentive. (There were only two other tables occupied.) Ambiance, not so much. Way too chilly on a cold winter's day. Half-dozen tables in a small, pretty much bare, area. Little bar with 2-3 barstools. Pizza was mediocre. "Wood Fired," but crust wasn't even browned, let alone showing even a bit of char. Barely any sauce, not many vegetables for a veggie pizza. And they were out of non-dairy cheese. Not worth the $26+ by any means.
