-
March 2024 by Kiki Furrow
Great corned beef and cabbage. Second visit I had the chicken and ribs, delicious!
-
March 2024 by Tiffani Kivisto
The day we went there were some issues with staffing so it took longer to get seated and the food was running out but they tried. The ribs were a little crisper than I prefer but maybe that's a personal preference. I haven't been there in a while but it's pretty much the same as I remember. Still wish you could get more than one apple slice!
-
March 2024 by MaryAnn Valencia
We love going to Fitzgerald 's whenever we get back to
-
March 2024 by P Quarters
Great place for a family dinner setting, to relax.
-
February 2024 by Maritza Cadena
The food never disappoints if you know what you're going for. We love the fish boil, potatoes, even the cole slaw is good. Brandy Old Fashions are nice and strong. Unfortunately, this visit was lacking service. We waited a while to order drinks - had to go order at the bar ourselves. We were well into our second course before the server made her way to our table. Can't even use the excuse that it was a busy night since we were seated right away in a half empty dining room. But its possible she was the only server for both floors. This won't stop us from going back when we're craving fishboil.
-
January 2024 by chris capcik
OUTSTANDING!!!!!! We went here last weekend for my stepdaughter's birthday and had an amazing time. It's not just dinner it's an experience.The owner & staff were top notch and the food was amazing! Do yourself a favor and just add the ribs & chicken for $3 extra. You will not be disappointed. We can't wait to be back!Don't forget to bring cash :)
-
January 2024 by Dawn Adenau
Love the outside of the building, but the inside seems an odd layout and decor is outdated. Staff and bar folks were very nice.
-
January 2024 by Dan Norton
True Wisconsin dining and superb supper club experience. All you can eat for and great price. You will want to purchase the ticket for all options as it's only a few dollars more and you get to have the best cod I've ever had as well as incredible chicken and ribs. Additionally, their coleslaw is the best I have ever had, although it's only a side, it made the meal for me. If you're lucky enough to get a table you are in for a fantastic experience.
-
November 2023 by Chuck Corcilius
Good food. Great place! Old home that was once a mansion!
-
November 2023 by Chris Williams
Best fish I've ever had. Always look forward to our Mother's Day Celebration here with friends and family. It looks like they're building up the exterior of the place to accommodate more folks. Kudos to your team and technique!Update: visited again and it reminded me how good fish can be. Great folks operating/cooking and serving. I always look forward to coming back!
-
November 2023 by Jeffrey Diedrich
Great place to get a Wisconsin fish boil. You can get a combination platter which is fish, BBQ chicken and BBQ ribs, just fish or just chicken. Their cole slaw was very good and the potatoes and onions were very good as well. If you are looking for fancy this is not the place. We put our plates in the server tub when we were done so we could get more. Everything is all you can eat. They do not take credit cards so bring cash. The meal was good and we did not walk away hungry.
-
October 2023 by Brandee Pettengill
What a gem! This place has the best cod I have ever had. Everything was delicious! The chicken thigh was also very good, it was nice and moist and I liked the barbecue sauce. The little red potatoes were amazing with those onions that were so sweet and delicious I could just make a meal out of those! The apple slab pie dessert was fabulous and I bake for a living so I am pretty picky! Thank you for a great meal!
-
September 2023 by Kim Scharine
SOOOOO GOOD!! Friday fish boil was amazing! The service was wonderful and very friendly. The old Victorian house is beautiful.
-
September 2023 by Janet Johnson
I had the fish and chicken dinner. So wonderful. Comes with slaw boiled potato, boiled onion, bread and apple slice for desert. I have been going there for over 20 years.
-
September 2023 by Skippy juan Jones
The fish is great but just one of the worst layout concepts I have ever seen in a restaurant. Must have lots of patience to dine here.
