-
March 2024 by Mari Brown
I got a beautiful sheet cake for a celebration of life. It was gorgeous and reasonable priced. I would recommend susie's sweetie LLC.
-
December 2023 by Philip Haapakoski
Great
-
November 2023 by Alicia Jackson
I have tried this place a few times and really want to like it. I love supporting small businesses etc. However, the lady that is in there is not very friendly, hardly smiles or interacts with you. Additionally, the baked goods are always SO dry. Like maybe they are old? Lastly, and the final straw for me, is that she barehands the sweets and passes them to you. I just think that's gross. Gloves are a must in my book especially when it's directly to the customer.
-
December 2022 by Katie Shaver
LOVE Susie and her darling bake shop!! She was able to accommodate my request on pretty short notice for custom cookies, and was so kind and helpful. And the cookies - SO cute and even more tasty!! Couldn’t recommend her more for all your baked good needs!
-
December 2022 by Abbey Benson
Great prices. One of the best white cakes and frosting I've ever tasted.
-
December 2022 by Christine Emmer
Very very yummy date bars! Such a cute bakery! All the decorated cup cakes and cakes are amazing! Everything tastes amazing
-
December 2022 by Logan Garey
Tom from Waunakee-key and ADC Lock was telling me that he’s never found anyone who can make a Raspberry rhubarb pie the way Suzie’s Sweetz does. When he told me he drives an hour one way to get this pie I knew I had to try it.LOVED IT! I toasted each slice I had to crisp it up fresh like. I even saved a piece of pie for my mom who flew in from North Carolina last night. She comes from a family of good cooks and pie makers.She had never had a Raspberry rhubarb pie and she said it was delicious! My mom is very critical about food so this is high praise from her. My wife and I agree with my mom, which doesn't always happen! Can’t wait to order this again!!!
-
November 2022 by Katie Osborn
LOVE Susie and her darling bake shop!! She was able to accommodate my request on pretty short notice for custom cookies, and was so kind and helpful. And the cookies - SO cute and even more tasty!! Couldn’t recommend her more for all your baked good needs!
-
July 2022 by chris stevenson
A nice little local bakery.The customer service has been excellent every time I've been here, courteous and polite, helpful where they can be.Over the summer months they have more available hours which makes it easier to stop in and get my fix of cheesecake.They make a lot of different things for which I have tried almost all of them, from cupcakes to cakes, cheesecake to pies, cookies to turnovers, and bread to rolls. They also provide Chocolate Shop Ice Cream, The best in Wisconsin!I would highly recommend stopping in here if you get the chance and definitely get the cheesecake!
-
June 2022 by Josh Holliday
Found this little shop that had big offerings. They exceeded our expectations. Not only did my granddaughter's cake look perfect but it tasted amazing. The cookies were also perfect. Thank you so much we will be back for sure.
-
June 2022 by Tracy Holliday
What an amazing little shop! We looked for a place that could do a cake for our granddaughter’s 4th birthday- and these ladies nailed it! From the design to the awesome flavor of the cake and frosting! We also ordered 3 dozen custom cookies, again nailed it!!
-
April 2022 by Abbey Foster
Great prices. One of the best white cakes and frosting I've ever tasted.
-
March 2022 by Lola Preuss
It's a really sweet little shop, reasonably priced and so delicious. Ordered petit fours for my daughter's birthday . They are beautiful and delicious.
-
August 2021 by Haile Taft
I ordered from suzies sweetz for my son's first birthday and I'm so glad I did I got what I was looking for! His smash cake and cookies turned out amazing plus really great price!
-
March 2021 by Kayla Schaller-Greenwood
Suzie did a fantastic job on our wedding cake. It both looked beautiful and tasted great! I was very impressed with her commitment to customer service. She was willing to make any flavor we requested and the quoted price as all encompassing (time, materials, delivery, set up.) She also is a strong advocate for not up charging just because it is a wedding cake. We've also purchased bread and cheesecake from her shop- everything is delicious!
