Pegasus Games is a popular local game store known for its wide selection of trading cards, board games, and miniatures. Customers from nearby areas, like South Bend, Indiana, travel just to visit, citing excellent service and a friendly atmosphere. The staff is helpful, knowledgeable, and always eager to assist, making both new and experienced gamers feel comfortable. The store offers a large inventory of items including Pokémon cards, D&D miniatures, Warhammer 40k books, and more. Many reviews highlight the store's welcoming vibe, with some customers mentioning that staff go above and beyond, such as giving energy cards for free or helping find specific items. Pegasus Games also provides spacious play areas and hosts game nights, which are highly recommended for making new friends and enjoying gaming. The store's environment is described as fun, chill, and supportive, making it a great place for nerds and gamers of all levels. Overall, Pegasus Games is considered one of the best gaming shops in Madison, praised for its variety, helpful staff, and positive community atmosphere.
Such a great place to hang out on a Saturday to play board games with other wonderful board game lovers. They have such a great selection of board games for purchase and a great selection of book nook items. Everyone there is super friendly and very helpful.
November 2025
Decent sized gaming store on the west side of Madison.
August 2025
Used to come here has a kid most prices are amazing and fair since getting back into magic I use them more and more vs other shops that charge scalper prices they actually care for the player the only reason for 4 stars is the trade in value other then that I'd recommend any mtg player shop here
