-
March 2024 by Julie Miles
Always wanted to stop here. Met friendly people and liked the Reuben rolls.
-
February 2024 by Rochelle L.
Such a fun spot in green lake area! Bartenders and staff are very friendly and a variety of food choices for everyone! It is a little pricier on the drink end though!
-
February 2024 by Steve E
Carry out beer, at the price of the same as is charged at the bar$ 3.50 per bottle or $21.00 for a six pack of domestic beer. Their prices on the mediocre food they serve isn't any better. I went to happy hour and when I asked the bartender what the happy hour prices are he had no idea they even had a happy hour what kind of bar doesn't have a happy hour? The price for the beer was $21 for plus tax out the door, liquor is already text at the bar and that would have been double taxation
-
December 2023 by Jan K.
Really good pub food and bar with good Wisconsin service. My crew enjoyed fish fry on Friday including cod and bluegill. Loved the potato pancake and Cole slaw sides. Returned on Saturday and loved the homemade lasagna special, BLT, and burger. Lots of beer choices including Knuth Brewing Blue Eyed Blond which is now a favorite. "Giggles" was the name of our server. Super nice gal. When near Green Lake Wisc this is a must stop.
-
November 2023 by Gab R.
Great all American (and some Irish) pub fare. Live that there are gluten free options. And glad water access is back!!
-
November 2023 by Joe Strelow
The service was absolutely horrible!! We got there at 6:30 and the bar was full so ordered drinks and waited in the back room after giving our name to the hostess. After seeing many people come in and get seated after us we questioned why we were ignored and we were told they called for us at the bar but never checked the back room. We ordered and still didn’t get our food until after 8:15. The waitress apologized a lot but complained she was sick. Just what I need a sick person serving us food……. Stay away folks!!!
-
November 2023 by S (John Doe)
I went in to purchase beer like I have a 100 times I've been here since 1965 and they wanted to charge me $21 for a six-pack of Miller high Life to go, They're not going to get many sales that way.
-
October 2023 by Eric Streich
Local here to the area. Live within 10 minutes of this place. I know a couple year's ago got new owners. Haven't been here since the old owners. To start off the place is a nice place. Always has been. No, the waitress took our drink order. Two bloody Mary's with beer chasers. Took easy 10 minutes to get our drinks. It wasn't worth the wait. Bloody Mary was the worst we have ever had, and we drink lots of bloodys through out the state. One never got touche, and I chocked mine down. Did let the waitress know but never made an adjustment for the one not drank. One to the food. One order was a hamburger. It was dry and over cooked. Never did get asked how they wanted it done. I had a fish basket. It was okay.There's nothing to brag about. Won't be back ever. If you can't make a drink within a few minutes when not busy. Need a new bartender and need to train waitstaff on how to be friendlier and as well take care of issues. This place will be closed within a few years unless it has major changes. O and I have managed pub and grill before and know what it takes to stay open. This place don't have it.
-
October 2023 by Brittany Huellen
LOVE Reilly’s so much!!! Food & drinks were great! One thing I do want to bring up is the bartenders seem so stressed to the point where their customers are feeling stressed with them. Yes, It’s busy,..but just take a breath! It’s okay!
-
September 2023 by R
Great food and nice bar.
-
September 2023 by Daniel Elsner
great food fantastic service on beautiful green
-
September 2023 by Mark Krueger
Chips n cheese taco dip. Bread styxs w/cheese dip. Very nice place to stop in have a beer n something to eat. Thank you
-
September 2023 by Tanya Marie Brandt
Just stopped in for a quick drink, after a nice boat ride.. bartender was nice and efficient.. will definitely stop in again and try some food.
-
September 2023 by Valerie P.
had to give at least one star but would like to have given them none - stopped by for ice cream - first girl just walked out on us and the second one told us that their tables was their priority and we would have to wait until someone was free to serve us - we waited about 10 mins and left. We'll use our money somewhere else where it is appreciated
-
August 2023 by Jeffery Martynski
Reilly's is fast becoming our go to place for a Fish fry. The atmosphere is relaxing, the food is excellent, and the Service is very good. The outdoor eating area is also nice if the humidity cooperates. I would recommend it to anyone.
