Toy Stores near Middleton, WI

7 locations found near Middleton
View Map

“I love this place. Yes, the games cost a bit more than Target or another big box store, BUT you're supporting the local community. And they have good variety. Even better, they have a great space in the back for gaming. My teen spends time here with friends playing games and afterwards they grab a snack from the co-op grocery store. Much better than getting into shenanigans.”

4.7 Superb20 Reviews

“A good selection of items, both new and pre-owned! They even carry stuff that you can usually only buy online through the Lego store. Prices are very reasonable on most items. Just like the Lego store, sets are separated by theme, to make it easier to find what you're looking for, and there is a build a minifigure station. The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable, and I would definitely visit again, if I'm in the area. 23/2024”

4.7 Superb35 Reviews

“This is a nice comic store with a variety of new comics, graphic novels, games, comic book back issues, statues, etc. The person that was working there was very well informed and helpful. The layout of the store made it easy to look at everything quickly. The store is located next to the Dollar Tree.”

4.8 Superb17 Reviews

“I bought a beautiful huipil from Chajul but the color was not right. I returned it, got credit minus shipping, and found one I love so much. The owner was professional and helpful; she will answer any questions you have before buying. Highly recommend this seller; she is ethical and honest, and does good work for artisans in Guatemala.”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“I LOVE shopping here! The lady at the front is always kind and friendly when we come in. The store is absolutely adorable with cute decorations and chandeliers. There is a large selection to choose from when we come and the prices are exactly what you would expect for second hand clothes.”

4.4 Superb45 Reviews

“Brock helped us out with all of our needs there. He gave us card recommendations and for local places to eat! I will recommend this place to anyone I talk to looking for any tcg products. Ask for Brock!”

4.3 Superb30 Reviews

“We were fortunate enough to work with Melissa.It was a long weekend of celebrating our 2-year-old son. Grandma drove back from Florida to be with us and she, my wife, and I arrived within 10 minutes of closing and she had 2 or 3 children ahead of us.In between working with the other families, she greeted us and our son with high, positive energy, and gave him the cute paper hat/crown while we waited our turn.She showed no signs of fatigue or impatience - I feel like if it were anywhere else they'd tell you "sorry we're closed" or "we won't be able to get to you today, our hours tomorrow are..." NOT Melissa! :)I hope Build-A-Bear corporate sees this to know that she is one of their best hires.Speaking for myself, I was a bit wound up and stressed (don't ask why - mom and grandma do all the heavy lifting) but Melissa's positive attitude and willingness to stay late to create such an awesome experience for our son meant so much to us and relieved the tension I was feeling.If you come here, it doesn't hurt to ask if Melissa working :)”

2.5 Average24 Reviews

Related Categories