Makes Cents Variety Store is a charming shop filled with a wide variety of vintage toys, figures, and games, offering a nostalgic experience for visitors. The store features an impressive selection of wrestling memorabilia and retro video games for all systems, making it a great stop for collectors and pop culture enthusiasts alike. Many customers appreciate the friendly and knowledgeable staff, who are dedicated to providing excellent service. However, there have been mixed experiences regarding the buying process, with some customers noting that certain employees may lack expertise in valuing collectibles. Despite this, many shoppers have found fair offers when dealing with the more experienced staff. The shop is well-organized and clean, showcasing items like TMNT, Barbie, Rainbow Brite, and more in a cozy setting. Customers enjoy the thrill of searching for unique finds, and the store has been described as a treasure trove of childhood memories. Whether looking to buy or sell, Makes Cents Variety Store offers a welcoming atmosphere and a diverse range of items that appeal to all ages. Overall, it is considered a must-visit for anyone interested in toys and collectibles.
Shout out to Chris very helpful amazing store amazing stuff like always love coming here
August 2026
Best shop in the area very knowledgeable fair prices and great customer service! Staple for Milwaukee area gamers
August 2026
I love coming to this shop! The owner was deffinatly knowledgeable and helped me worh some personal game knowledge! Prices are within reason thank you for that! Deffinatly a fun place to visit brings back my childhood and beyond every time!
