Casey's in Monticello, Wisconsin, offers a variety of services including fresh, made-from-scratch pizza with real mozzarella cheese and fresh toppings. Customers can also enjoy appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a selection of household essentials and groceries. The store provides fuel with quality fuels for those needing to fill up. Staff members, like Amanda, are known for their kindness, helpfulness, and genuine service, often going above and beyond to assist customers. Customers frequently praise the friendly and caring staff, with some describing staff as helpful, generous, and even deserving of recognition or a raise. In addition to food and essentials, the store features a popular grilled chicken salad, noted for its good taste and affordability compared to other options. Overall, Casey’s in Monticello is appreciated for its friendly service, tasty food, and convenient offerings for everyday needs.
We ended up in Monticello by accident. Stopped to use the restrooms (kinda clean)
September 2026
Half the fuel pumps didnt work and the layout of the pumps is silly overall got fuel and went back on my way
June 2026
Stopped at Casey's in PDC to grab pizza slices and Mountain Dew. Grabbed the last pieces of a sausage and a pepperoni; big mistake. Both were not edible...
