-
October 2023 by Holly Hang
Was looking for an estate piece to replace my lost wedding set. I found the most beautiful ring. So glad I stopped in. Service was great (never felt pressured to make a purchase)
-
September 2023 by Liam
I went here to get my bracelet resized to fit me, expecting to be really expensive because I thought all jewelry shops were like that. But no! He comes out with it all done and says “don’t worry it’s on me.”I then proceed to ask him questions about stuff and he was super helpful with all of them and then helping me be 100% positive with my purchase. Everyone there is super nice and helpful and amazingly respectful. If you’re looking for anything to do with jewelry, go here!
-
August 2023 by Linda Ottman
My son had a titanium ring stuck on his finger. He wore it for 25 years. After going to Urgent Care, they couldn’t cut it so on the outside chance that J Anthony Jewelers could help I stopped in. Such very nice people and yes they got it off. I certainly was more than willing to pay, but they said no charge! In today’s world I cannot believe the great customer service and kindness my son was shone. Any jewelry needs will be taken care of at J Anthony in Neenah in the future! Outstanding business!
-
August 2023 by Tim Marta
Joe made me a custom piece that exceeded all of my expectations. A piece that will be in my family forever. Beyond happy with the entire experience. Would rate 10 stars if I could.
-
July 2023 by William Mccarthy
Excellent experience. Of all the jewelers in the valley, these are the best. For repairs, new jewelry, good selection, etc.
-
June 2023 by Chase Lyles
I’ve gone through J. Anthony twice now. They provide excellent customer service, are prompt and have been able to save me a lot of money compared to other places I’ve looked. Love them and don’t want to go anywhere else!
-
May 2023 by Marley Kercher
I recently worked with J. Anthony to get a replacement for my platinum wedding band which I unfortunately lost. Everything about the experience was wonderful: the personal service, quality and selection of rings and the coordination with my insurance company. I have purchased jewelry from them previously as well, including a necklace i had made from my original engagement solitaire diamond. They created a beautiful design and I get compliments on it every time I wear it. This kind of service and attention to detail is what I think really distinguishes J. Anthony from the big box stores and I feel fortunate to have them in our community.
-
May 2023 by Ethan Robinson
I have bought from this location twice, once for an engagement ring, and once for wedding bands. The representatives were super helpful and not pushy even when I did not know exactly what I wanted. I was able to have them help me figure out what I wanted without feeling like I was being pushed towards the most expensive items or most traditional.
-
October 2022 by Lisa C.
Had a ring made here in 2020, stone fell out so I took it back and they only have a one year warranty. Setting was cracked and this ring was only worn a few hrs a week. No help. Told me to call my homeowners insurance.
-
October 2022 by Lindsey Wax
J Anthony Jewlers have now fixed TWO pieces for me. They go above and beyond with every service. The quality and workmanship is top notch and their prices are very affordable. I will never shop anywhere else!
-
September 2022 by lily pfantz
I absolutely loved working with kim she made every part of my ring exchange of the stone perfect the communication was great i cant say thank you enough i am so in love with my upgrade
-
June 2022 by Kathy Searl
This place is amazing! I first came in to have a ring appraised. The work was completed within a few days. Then I decided to have the ring sized. I had a wedding coming up that I wanted to wear it for. They went out of their way to make sure everything was done on time. Everybody is so friendly and helpful! My new favorite jewelers!
-
April 2022 by Candi Lamb
I have wanted to have a custom ring made for years. No one would do it for me. I moved to WI in January, and my sister-in-law brought me to J. Anthony Jewelers. They were wonderful! So nice, professional, and honest. They made my custom ring without question. They are true artists there! I definitely recommend them for all your jewelry needs!
-
April 2022 by Baron Schuler
Brought in a couple of large Topaz crystals to have cufflinks crafted out of them. The J Anthony people were very accommodating in sourcing the necessary Jigs to get the work done and they did create some exceptional looking cufflinks. Was very pleased with their work and the turn around time. Will bring a more challenging item in for them in the near future, gem stones with small diamonds incorporated as well. Look forward to seeing what they can do.Very Happy Customer!
-
April 2022 by C v
I can not say enough GREAT THINGS ABOUT J. ANTHONY JEWELERS!!! I stopped in as I wanted to find the perfect Gold cross for my daughter who is getting confirmed. I did NOT want to go to a mall jeweler and get Lord knows what, but wanted a real home town trusted Jeweler I knew I could trust. They had a few in store, but not what what this picky proud mama had in mind. So here comes Ben with a huge book of tons of options!! He measured, he turned pages, he checked sizes in the store, had my other daughter send me a picture of her cross for size reference, Ben measured that even!! WE FOUND IT!! 2 days later I was running back to get them ( I bought 2) PERFECT IS THE WORD!! Ben had the chains in store and OH my LORD I AM SO EXCITED TO GIVE THIS TO HER!!! BEN AND THE STAFF WERE AMAZING !!!! AND I WILL NEVER GO ELSEWHERE!!! ( I said as I was literally jumping for joy with excitment when I left!! really you can ask them:) THANK YOU EVER SO MUCH J. ANTHONY!!!Blessings,Cheri Van Asten
