Pet Supplies Plus Oconomowoc is a local pet store that has everything pet owners need for their furry, scaly, and feathery friends. The store is stocked with a wide selection of natural and made-in-the-USA products, with prices that customers love. Shoppers can easily find their pets' favorites, whether they visit the store in person or use the convenient online ordering with free curbside pickup or same-day delivery. Customers praise the store's friendly and helpful staff, who provide a positive experience for both owners and their pets. The team is particularly praised for their patience and care when working with reactive or wary pets, making the grooming experience easier for both the animal and the owner. The store is also noted for its cleanliness and organization, creating a welcoming environment for all. While there have been a few instances of miscommunication around pricing, the overall sentiment from customers is overwhelmingly positive. Pet Supplies Plus Oconomowoc is a beloved local business that provides exceptional service and a wide selection of products for the community's beloved pets.
Always come here and get the dog wash pass for my husky malamute and the staff is always so friendly and nice. I never feel like a burden with all the hair.
February 2026
Love that they offer such a large variety of food and treats!
December 2025
Love this place! Staff is so friendly and helpful! Clean atmosphere with lots of options for all your pets needs.
