-
March 2024 by Heidi Wilson
They have great food. Caleb runs a nice restaurant. It is a very homey atmosphere.
-
March 2024 by scott mellington
Food was good. Kinda spendy for portion size. We went for fish and you get two sides. Our friend asked if they could get double steamed vegetables and waitress says yes then they got charged extra for them even though they only got two sides. Thought that was unfair or should have been told they would be charged
-
February 2024 by James Kremmer
Upon walking into Mary Cody's, you're treated with a nice replica of what would be an Irish pub. It's a great environment, nice and cozy for great conversation.This being my first visit, I'm sure I had that face of "What am I doing here, I need help!" I was quickly greeted and had the cream of the crop for eating locations, I took saddle at the bar.Looking at the limited menu for breakfast, everything was tempting. I took the following: Meat Lover's Skillet, Eggs Benedict, Biscuits and Homemade Sausage Gravy, and Buttermilk Pancakes.Meat Lovers SkilletIt was expected. Well executed. I didn't need to season the dish. Came out fresh. Nothing to write home about, but their take on the Meat Lovers Skillet is solid. Let's be honest, can be purchased anywhere in the area.Eggs BenedictEggs were runny and perfect. I'd happily buy again.Biscuits and Homemade Sausage GravyHANDS DOWN, the best sit-down biscuits and gravy in the area! Most restaurant have Chef Mic(rowave) in the back, nuking biscuits and gravy. Not here! You can tell that this dish is made from scratch. I'd love to take an IV direct into my vein and just pipe the gravy into my bloodstream. *Chef's Kiss*Buttermilk PancakesPancakes are hearty and filling. I'd have no problems recommending the pancakes here.If you're looking for value and QUANTITY, go somewhere else. If you're looking for a true under the radar breakfast place, with great and quick service, friendly atmosphere, and all the dishes coming out perfect and fresh. It's worth the money. Easily a top 10 hidden gem breakfast spot in the LaCrosse/Onalaska area.Biscuits and gravy, BEST IN THE AREA.
-
January 2024 by Hollie Wyman
Excellent Staff, Excellent Food, Friendly People, Nice Ambiance & Atmosphere, ThankYou Sincerely & See You Very Soon,
-
December 2023 by Andrew McElroy
My burger only came with cheese (no toppings other than bottles of mustard and ketchup) and the patty was un-/underseasoned. Surprised to get corn-on-the-cob as a side, but sadly it tasted bland. Girlfriend’s baked cod was also a little bland. French fries were perfect but skimpy due to sharing the plate with a corn cob.
-
December 2023 by Kaila Langrehr
My only go to for live music when at home.....love love
-
October 2023 by Jordan Linders
Heard great things about this place for Friday Fish. Got it for takeout, but the food was mashed together in the container. I'll have to give them another shot, because the fish that I could eat was good.
-
October 2023 by John Evans
Great food and drinks. Cozy
-
August 2023 by Emylee Walker
Last night after calling multiple places just to find out their kitchen was closed, I came across Mary Cody’s. Despite their kitchen already being closed, the cook opened back up just for us to be able to place an order. We ended up ordering burgers and fries, which were amazing. The burgers were huge and the buns we soft and tasted so good. I highly recommend and we will definitely be back!
-
June 2023 by Ryan Capwell
Some plans changed for a Mother's Day event and we ended up pivoting to trying Mary Cody's. Their Mother's Day brunch was a reservation only and on my first attempt to see if we could get in, we were advised to call back in about 30 minutes to see if they could fit us in. When we called back 30 minutes we were told they would be able to squeeze us in between some other reservations. We were seated right away, albeit at a high top, and with a young child the table wasn't ideal. Once a table cleared, Caleb (one of their staff members) immediately cleaned off a low top and offered us to move to the low top. We were able to enjoy an amazing Mother's Day brunch in such a last minute decision. A few hours later I received a call from Caleb saying "Hey I believe you left your diaper bag at our restaurant and we will be here for another hour if you want to come pick it up." It was unknown to either myself, or my wife, that we had left the diaper bag behind. The entire Mary Cody's staff, especially Caleb, went above and beyond to provide us a great experience. You won't find a more accommodating place, with excellent service, and amazing food in the area than you will find at Mary Cody's!
-
June 2023 by Judith Skifton
Good food lots of it! Excellent waitress and not too expensive. We will be back! The only downside is limited parking but the short walk in the rain was worth it!?
-
April 2023 by Michelle Wilcox
First time visit. Service was prompt and welcoming. Food was delicious. Will be my new go-to place for fish!
-
March 2023 by Lisa Grinde
On top of my list of favorites! Wonderful food and drink, friendly caring service, cozy atmosphere with the perfect touch of elegance.
-
January 2023 by Dave Heilman
Very good Friday night fish. Friendly and prompt service. I would recommend.
-
November 2022 by Joy Propp
Was very disappointed as it was not open at 9 am on a Tuesday even though it was listed as open on its website and times listed on door. We had only a couple hours to spend so it seriously cost us an outing.
