Auto Insurance near Pewaukee, WI

16 locations found near Pewaukee

“We switched to State Farm Ins. last December. To say that we have been overly impressed with Brandi and her team is an understatement. Our family was severely affected with the horrible flooding this past August and Brandi has been so helpful throughout the entire process. She even called and texted just to check in on us. Calls are returned within an hour, emails are replied to promptly and she is very professional. Couldn't be happier with our switch!”

4.9 Superb33 Reviews

“John is fantastic to work with! He was my agent during the flooding that occurred in the Milwaukee area in August of 2025. He was always super responsive when I reached out for support regarding my claim. I’d highly recommend working with him.”

5 Superb109 Reviews

“Nathan does great work and he was very easy to work with. He had just recently helped me set up my car insurance and everything went smoothly. He worked with me on my situation, got me a great policy with the necessary coverage, and saved me money in the process. If I could select 6 out of 5 stars I would. I would make Christy Celeste and State Farm your first stop for sure.”

5 Superb52 Reviews

“My son was in an accident and Margaret and her team went above and beyond!! After he got a new car he was getting a loan and needed proof of insurance on a Saturday night and Margret made sure she took care of us!!!! Best Insurance Agent and team!!! I highly recommend!

Amy Osmus”

4.9 Superb61 Reviews

“I have been with Joe Carrigan as an agent since I was a student in college looking to insure my first car. That was 30 years ago. He and Tina always work hard and are diligent in finding me the most affordable and reliable insurance. They have decades in this business from which to draw a vast knowledge and are great liaisons between insurance companies when claims occur. They are kind, caring, and look out for me, I think, just as they would a family member.”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“A while back, I had been dropped from my previous agency and was having trouble finding insurance at a reasonable rate. I got a hold of Jose from Lehmann Insurance and he was able to take care of my vehicle and homeowners needs. Reasonable rates and great service have made me a very happy customer and I highly recommend Lehmann.”

4.9 Superb33 Reviews

“Hunter was great, he took the time to listen to my situation and was able to help me get a new policy right away for both Auto and Renters Insurance. On top of that, he saved me over $100 in monthly payments. Talk about great customer service!”

4.9 Superb57 Reviews

“Alan and his staff are always extremely helpful. When we had an issue at our home they helped us step by step to fix the issue. If I call when they are on the phone or with a client, he always calls back within 30 minutes. He has great customer service skills and always has a positive attitude. I highly recommend using Alan as your State Farm insurance agent!”

5 Superb18 Reviews

“At the recommendation of a neighbor, we began using the Linda Carney office for All American insurance since we moved to Wisconsin 15 years ago. Initially, this was to cover home and auto (2 vehicles), however, based on service and value over time we added boat, motorcycle, 2 additional vehicles and an umbrella policy. I would highly recommend considering the Linda Carney agency for your insurance needs.”

4.8 Superb26 Reviews

“Melissa Allen agency in the Falls is my 3rd AmFam agent. She & her staff, Tenisha, helped me get my 1099 business insurance policy completed when I was out-of state. Impressive!! Every time I reach out to my insurance agent I get a prompt, accurate & helpful response. Additionally, I dont get oodles of junk mail asking me to buy more coverage. Her office is close to my home, stylish, and on-point. Would highly recommend.”

4.8 Superb21 Reviews

“I was with Progressive for many years and went into complete and total shock when their prices went through the roof when I got a different car. I've had nothing on my record for years. I called State farm and their rates were less than what I was paying originally with Progressive for better coverage. I have been really happy with this agency! Every time I've had a question or something. Someone is always there to answer and they go above and beyond.”

4.6 Superb29 Reviews

“I’ve had a great experience working with Jacquie and Paul at State Farm. Jacquie has been incredibly responsive, helpful, and thorough in making sure I understand my policy and get the best coverage for my needs. Paul was also very friendly and took the time to introduce himself, which made me feel welcome.

As a younger customer, I really appreciate that they never tried to take advantage of me or push anything unnecessary—instead, they took the time to explain everything clearly and help me make informed decisions. Their professionalism and customer service have been top-notch, and I’d highly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable insurance support!”

4.6 Superb32 Reviews

“Dane was great! I hadn't switched insurance in over 15 years and he was able to get me a great quote on home/auto very quickly and with very competitive rates! He was very quick to respond to my questions and got everything setup very quickly.”

4.5 Superb24 Reviews

“We have had exceptional customer service with Steve E. He found us good coverage for home and auto at the best price I have ever paid. I recommend to everyone I know.”

4.6 Superb46 Reviews

“I have been a State Farm customer for over 30 years, more than 15 of those years with Sam Hunt and his staff as my agent and insurance team. Sam's professionalism and customer service have exceeded that of his predecessors. I have always received excellent professional advice, whether there was a claim issue, a coverage question, or something as simple as changing my mailing address, Sam and his team have always been there when I needed them. I highly recommend the Sam Hunt State Farm agency.”

4.6 Superb69 Reviews

“This agency is professional, friendly, knowledgeable, and responsive. Melanie and Ben always answer my questions and help when needed. Highly recommend to everyone!”

3.9 Good34 Reviews