-
April 2024 by Diana Anderson
Classic supper club vibe. Food was awesome. Service friendly.
-
April 2024 by Anne L.
This restaurant is absolutely beautiful, the remodel is stunning from outdoor fireplace features, the bathrooms, light fixtures, seating, etc. Not to mention the lake views. Great job. We were a party of 4 that reside in Elkhorn so we were thrilled upon entering to have such a great new place to go and take our friends. We were seated 15-20 minutes past our reservation time of 7:30, I thought this a bit odd but not a big deal, we just enjoyed a drink at the bar. We were eventually seated at a beautiful table at the windows overlooking the water. Things spiraled from there. We had a lot of wait time. Our server was friendly and informative but she was a bit personally affronted when my husband told her the beer he received was not the one he had wanted. This shouldn't even be a blip on a server's radar. Apologize, take it away and bring the new one. No attitude, just done. The menu was great although they were out of filets. Not really sure how that happens at a place that prides themselves on steaks. We received soup and salad at 9, our meals at 9:30. Not great at all for having a 7:30 reservation. Our orders consisted of one walleye and 3 ribeyes. The steaks were warmish and the veggies were cold. We did tell the server but we were hungry at this point and were ok with keeping what we had. The problem was the temp, not the food itself. She told the chef and the response was that that couldn't be. What? 3 out of 4 people at a table comment that their food is cold and "chef" disputes that? Once again, an apology was all that was needed and an offer to make it right. We did have the option to re-order or warm it up, but what's with the attitude again? I really really wanted to like this restaurant and we will try again. We were just so disappointed with our experience that night.
-
April 2024 by N W
Our favorite date night spot. The food is amazing we never leave without the home made desserts but the service is what really brings us back time and time again. The best model of Wisconsin hospitality!
-
March 2024 by Kristy O'Brien Geary
Prime rib was delicious!
-
March 2024 by Laura O.
You can feel the TLC in everything they do --the food, service, and overall good vibes. Always accommodating and variety of things to choose from. Looking forward to going back soon!
-
March 2024 by Laura Kayler (Laura Elizabeth)
I always wanted to go to The Village Supper Club for Friday night fish fry,tonight was my night 3-8-2024.This supper club is delicious and a must ? The restaurant is small with about 15 tables and a very nice bar area.They surve in courses first clam chowder soup followed by a 4 piece cod dinner with your choice of sides(I got a baked potato)It was fantastic and we were so full.Price is very reasonable $36.00 for 2 people.(forgot to mention it also comes with a salad)
-
March 2024 by David Walitzer
Dont let the name fool ya. Last time we we there was pre-covid. Stopped in for amazing fish fry…served family style with amazing fish…potato pancakes and all the trimmings….and the entire establishment is changed to New and improved. Ha ha. Mediocre at best….with high prices. Like they are trying to compete with Lake Geneva establishments. I had gone up there in the “outdated” atmosphere since I was 10 years old. Huge disappointment. Never going there again Friday night fish fry was horrible. Another lost piece of history.
-
February 2024 by Patrick Johnson
Very nice!!
-
February 2024 by Crystal Mecham
Really cozy space, with straight forward great tasting food and craft cocktails. Will definitely be heading back. It is not a large space so be sure to make a reservation or take your chance with getting a spot at the bar.
-
February 2024 by Meg MacKenzie
We went with a group of 10 for an 8:30 pm reservation. We didn't get seated until 9:00 pm. We waited for over an hour for our food to arrive, once food started to come out, 4 out of our 10 people were still waiting. I ordered the ribeye medium well, I received a rare, cold ribeye. For a $35 ribeye, I'd expect more than what we received. Our table also had a chicken dish, which looked like baby food, no flavor or color. Out of the 10 people, 4 enjoyed their meals. The atmosphere is nice, but parking is horrible, we had to drive around for 10 minutes before we could get in. We will not be returning, for almost a $800 meal, we were all very disappointed. Do not waste your money!
-
February 2024 by Richard Hartmann
Service was outstanding, Atmosphere was rememberable! Food was okay, however my taste buds are little off.
-
February 2024 by Debi B
Love this little supper club!
-
January 2024 by Michelle Gibson
Charming little space with attentive and friendly service (shout out to Michelle and Jason)! The food was delicious as well! The spaghetti squash was amazing and the poor man’s lobster was flavorful! Cocktails were average but overall a great experience. Will definitely return!
-
January 2024 by John Frost
Great supper club. Super nice people and great food.
-
January 2024 by Renee Dalman
First time visiting this establishment and it was well worth it. Michelle was an excellent server and the food was fabulous. The prime rib was so flavorful as was were the twice baked. Potato soup was wonderful as well. The food and service were amazing and at a reasonable price. Will be back again.
