Bargains Unlimited is a well-organized thrift store located near Main Street in Sister Bay. It offers a large selection of items, including clothes, kitchen items, and an assortment of other goods. Prices are generally reasonable, especially during sales like the half-off clothing, and the store provides good deals for the Door County area. The staff, including managers Kristine and Sharon, are known for being kind and helpful. The store is conveniently set up, making shopping easy, and it has an ATM for cash purchases since credit cards are not accepted. While some items are older or more expensive compared to other thrift stores, visitors often find worthwhile items, such as an ideal area rug or kitchen supplies. Reviews mention that discovering treasures is part of the experience, though not every visit guarantees finding what one needs. Overall, Bargains Unlimited is worth a visit for bargain hunters and those looking for unique finds in a friendly atmosphere.
My fav place in Door! Ignore those other reviews- these people are great! I’ve been going here for over 15 years and always find great deals, quality stuff, wide variety and super nice volunteer workers. Treat them with respect people.
June 2026
Hard not to find something . Learned inventory & staff is donated. Proceeds going to local charities. Left with some cool items.
May 2026
Great place to donate your unwanted items. The staff is welcoming and helpful. The manager Kristine is wonderful and kind.
