Collector's Choice Coins is a full-service coin store that specializes in buying and selling rare coins, currency, and collectibles. The business is known for its honesty and fair pricing, with customers appreciating the seamless process and detailed appraisals of their collections. The owner has a strong reputation for being trustworthy and knowledgeable, often providing valuable insights into the coins customers bring in. Many reviews highlight the welcoming atmosphere, friendly service, and the presence of a charming onsite dog. The store also offers coin supplies and is willing to do house calls for those unable to visit. With over ten years of experience, Collector's Choice Coins is recommended for anyone looking for fair prices and a reliable coin dealer.
Nice shop, good staff, a good amount of inventory as well. (Good staff includes the dog)
April 2026
Absolutely an amazing place to go John is very respectable and very very talented and knows his coins very well I do business with him very often 10/10 would recommend him with anyone’s coins collections very fair prices buying and selling!!!
August 2025
We had various pieces of jewelry that we wanted to sell. John took his time to sort through everything and gave us a good price. Very easy to work with and communicated well. We will be returning, and highly recommend.
