Auto Insurance near Sussex, WI

15 locations found near Sussex
View Map

“Just got off the phone with Nathan here, and was amazed at how prepared he was; and how fast the whole process took.He worked with me on my situation and got me a great policy with the necessary coverage and saved me money in the process.I would make Christy Celeste and State Farm your first stop.”

5 Superb40 Reviews

“I have been with this insurance company for many years, it is nice for me that they have moved so much closer for me as I am disabled. They always remember me whether I call in or come in in person.”

5 Superb17 Reviews

“I have been with Joe Carrigan as an agent since I was a student in college looking to insure my first car. That was 30 years ago. He and Tina always work hard and are diligent in finding me the most affordable and reliable insurance. They have decades in this business from which to draw a vast knowledge and are great liaisons between insurance companies when claims occur. They are kind, caring, and look out for me, I think, just as they would a family member.”

5 Superb16 Reviews

“Melissa Allen agency in the Falls is my 3rd AmFam agent. She & her staff, Tenisha, helped me get my 1099 business insurance policy completed when I was out-of state. Impressive!! Every time I reach out to my insurance agent I get a prompt, accurate & helpful response. Additionally, I dont get oodles of junk mail asking me to buy more coverage. Her office is close to my home, stylish, and on-point. Would highly recommend.”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“Sam is the best. We have been with State Farm since 1992 and there is no better Ins Co out there. Sam always follows through and makes sure to explain what our options are to ensure we have the protection we need. There are never any pressured sales techniques...Just honest assessments. Steve & Debra Krejci”

4.8 Superb42 Reviews

“Joe has provided all of our insurance needs from auto, home, life, to recreational vehicles for the past 4 years and his service has always been excellent. He is incredibly efficient, professional, and pro active in making sure that everything we need is not only covered but that we’re always getting the best rates.”

4.8 Superb26 Reviews

“We have had our insurance with Rog Rogers for 30+ years. Rog and the office staff are honest, responsive, easy going and very friendly. We have appreciated how they work with us to get the most value for our auto, home, term life, etc.”

5 Superb8 Reviews

“I recently made the switch to State Farm and I'm incredibly impressed with the customer service at this agency in particular. I get prompt responses every time and the claim process has been a breeze. I would highly recommend Joe and Chrissy to anyone. I'm so glad that I changed agencies!”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“Best guy I know! And the entire team at the Paul Conradson Agency is top notch! Super helpful, kind and they know their stuff! Would recommend to anyone! Good ole fashioned personal service you just cant find anymore.”

4.7 Superb13 Reviews

“Debbie is polite, knowledgeable and quick to take care of any questions or concerns. She Works to find you the best rates for your situation and is prompt to reply when necessary - Highly recommended ?”

4.7 Superb13 Reviews

“We have had exceptional customer service with Steve E. He found us good coverage for home and auto at the best price I have ever paid. I recommend to everyone I know.”

4.7 Superb12 Reviews

“A while back, I had been dropped from my previous agency and was having trouble finding insurance at a reasonable rate. I got a hold of Jose from Lehmann Insurance and he was able to take care of my vehicle and homeowners needs. Reasonable rates and great service have made me a very happy customer and I highly recommend Lehmann.”

4.8 Superb4 Reviews

“I was shopping for insurance quotes for the rental properties that I managed because my current insurer Farmers decided to jack up their renewal premiums significantly. The new premiums for all my properties were unexpectedly high. I had been a loyal Farmers customer for about 30 years starting with my auto insurance and had never made a claim. I understood that with all these natural disasters happening around the country, Farmers (and all insurers) would increase their rates but not by the huge increase that they decide to put onto my policies especially for a client with several policies with them and had never filed a claim. It did not pay to be a loyal customer.I lucked out and found Lee Morehouse (from Allstate). His quotes were very competitive - comparing the same coverages and limits. He even lowered some of my existing coverages that were deemed excessive and this helped to save me some money too. Lee was extremely responsive, especially via emails and phone calls. He was very easy and nice to talk with, unlike another agent from another company that I encountered during this "shopping trip". Lee was not pushy at all. I felt he tried to create a connection with his customers. One of the rental properties failed a 3rd party inspection due to some minor roof shingles that they said were lifting. We thought the inspection on the roof shingles was a little unreasonable. Lee went above and beyond, climbed up the roof and caulked the lifting shingles in place, took photos and submitted an appeal. The appeal was approved and the policy was reinstated. I was very skeptical that it would work initially because I did not know how the insurance companies work. Lee was extremely helpful and I did not expect this to happen, maybe because I moved all my policies over to Allstate? In addition, Lee was on top of everything. Some of the policies did not receive the payments from the properties' escrow accounts promptly and pending cancellation, Lee made sure that the escrow accounts had received the proper paperwork and checked every now and then that Allstate received the payments. I also did my part to ensure that payments were deducted from the escrow accounts to prevent a cancellation.Even though the Allstate Insurance Agent was listed as Brandon Bystol, I had not met him or talked to Brandon. It was Lee that I worked with the entire time. This seemed a bit strange to me as I was used to only talking to the agent of the company. The other thing is when I called the main office phone number, it would always connect to a "smart" voice system, and sometimes it redirected to another office which is not the office that I need to reach. You would have to say the magic word "Agent" to be redirected to Brandon Bystol office. I wished there was just a direct office number I could call without having to go to a "smart" voice system.If you are looking for a quote, please do not hesitate to give Lee a call. I would highly recommend him.”

4.6 Superb43 Reviews

“I have been with Linda @ Linda L Carney agency for most of my adult life. As I approach 67 I have learned to appreciate good service from people you trust. Thanks Linda”

4.6 Superb14 Reviews

“Thanks to the Aylsworth team for a great experience in managing all of our policies. We've worked with Melanie closely for the last few years, and she's always very responsive, knowledgeable and pleasant to work with. We always feel that our questions are clearly addressed and that we're in good hands!”

4.6 Superb9 Reviews