-
December 2023 by Matt Lorfeld
The breakfast burrito was the bomb!
-
October 2023 by Kelsey B
This location doesn’t show up on the company website when you search for Casey’s locations in WI…what’s up with that? Is it independently owned somehow?
-
August 2023 by Wade Schafer
Better get there early. Closing at 8 means 7:45.
-
August 2023 by Heath Applegate
Went for lunch no food ready will not visit again
-
February 2023 by Makin' Memories
Where to start… 50% of the time this store isn’t open during their posted hours. Closing early, opening late. Odd hours as well, they don’t open until 7:00 am. Recently they had a “snow day”. I guess due to the snow they couldn’t be open. Tried to get gas this morning but the pumps were off. I’d consider the Casey’s in Verona to be more of an inconvenience store rather than convenience. Kwik Trip is able to do the basic things like be open during posted hours and during routine Wisconsin weather.
-
October 2022 by Elizabeth Thomas
I guess they like to close 15 minutes early now. Nice.
-
September 2022 by Mike Toral
Just realized that I could order pizza here? This is awesome!!
-
August 2022 by Jordan Oneil
Disappointed with the lack of employees presence when it’s busy. Much higher prices on bottled soda than Kwik Trip. Can’t recommend this store
-
May 2022 by Marty Muffler
I'm always impressed by the friendly and helpful staff. This location always has fresh clean restrooms and a clean and well light store.
-
May 2022 by Paul Sahy
Not open early enough. You have to scan your rewards to get gas rewards, must enter the store.
-
February 2022 by Arya Macvilay
I would rate zero if I could. Terrible customer service and a very rude manager. I placed an online order directly through Casey’s website and when it was delivered my pizza was missing. Called Casey’s and spoke with an employee who confirmed that my pizza was still at the store and that he was looking at it as we spoke. The employee told me that they cannot do anything and for me and to call DoorDash. Upon calling DoorDash, they told me that I would need to speak directly to the store since the order was placed directly through the Casey’s website. I was then transferred me to a very rude manager at Casey’s, Alicia, who initially tried to tell me that they did give the pizza to the delivery driver until I told her that I had already spoke with someone who had confirmed that my pizza was still at the store. She then seemed to be upset that she was caught lying and was unwilling to help and told me that she was unable to refund me and that I would need to speak to DoorDash. I called DoorDash again three more times and was told that I would need to speak with Casey’s in order to be refunded since the order was placed on Casey’s website and they are the ones who collected my payment. I also work for a local restaurant in Verona that also uses DoorDash, and we ARE able to provide refunds directly from our POS without the need of DoorDash, regardless of if the order came from our website or DoorDash. Not only were they unwilling to help me get refunded, but not once did they show concern about getting my food to me. I have now called DoorDash three more times and each person has confirmed that I would need to be refunded by Casey’s. I then tried calling Casey’s three times and the phone is now disconnected. Two of the representatives that I spoke with at DoorDash also tried to call the store multiple times and got no answer, and I am still yet to be refunded. Very shady manager and employees. I just wanted some breakfast pizza….
-
January 2022 by scott woods
Not open at 6:30 am . People inside but closed
-
December 2021 by John W.
Casey's selection of soft drinks, candy, and beef jerky is second to none! Their pizza is really good as well....and not just for a gas station. They have great sandwiches and other food items too. They offer a great variety of household and automotive products just in case you need something in a pinch. The building and bathrooms are always very clean and the staff is always pleasant to me. In fact, one time I went there a lady's car battery had died and one of the staff jumped her car for her. They're awesome people!
-
July 2021 by Ashley A
I had been craving taco pizza so went on a full blown search. This was recommended to me. So good! Highly recommend. I ordered delivery and it was packaged well and kept warm. The toppings were fresh, and it was nice I could put add ons. Who knew a gas station could have such good pizza
-
April 2021 by Jennifer Prince
I always like coming here. It's always really clean and the staff is always really nice. I also love that they have carwashes half off on Wednesdays, major plus because I baby my car and wash it 2 to 3 times a week during the winter to try and keep the salt off as much as possible. There are only 2 things I don't like about this place. 1, the hours. They don't open until 7am and they close at 10pm. I realize we are still in the middle of a pandemic which is why this doesn't affect my star rating. I just wish it was morelike 6am to 11pm. And 2, So even though the hours are 7am-10pm the pumps are still open where you can get gas using your debit and or credit card BUT they keep the lights off and early in the morning it is PITCH BLACK!!! I am a kidnapping survivor and I do not feel safe or comfortable getting out of the car getting gas when the gas station is this dark. I'm always a loyal customer with businesses I like and I feel bad that I cannot get gas there if I am on the road early in the morning. I will not get gas there with it being that dark. It would be really cool if they could leave the lights on at the pumps during closed hours since the pumps are technically still open. Still giving them 5 stars because I like Casey's so much. Oh and for a gas station, their pizza is better than most places. Just throwing that out there because who doesn't like decent pizza. Lol
