-
April 2024 by M B
I Love Sugar River, I sware it some of the best pizza in the area
-
April 2024 by Isaiah Southward
Amazing pizza, especially after a big competition ?
-
April 2024 by Ludwig Schaefer
Good place for a great pizza and out of the ordinary sandwiches.
-
April 2024 by JAN Sesvold
This is our favorite restaurant. Food is excellent.sometines there is a wait to be seated, but they always get you a table sooner than they say it will take. Everyone is extremely nice. The on line ordering could not be any easier and fast.Love this restaurant!
-
April 2024 by Rod R.
We order takeaway from this pizza place every time we have a celebration at work. Be it for birthdays or any other occasion. They always come through with the best pizza and excellent customer service. Love that they provide plates and cutlery with our orders!
-
April 2024 by Patrick Kastelic
Some of the best pizza in town. Good drink specials, too.
-
April 2024 by Cliff C
Best pizza in madison
-
April 2024 by dante Rubio
We’ve given Sugar River Pizza two chances. The first one was so so. The spinach and artichoke app was decent. Pizza came out like soup in the middle. Dough completely raw. No problem, we asked if they could just fire it longer. They said they had to just make a new one. Again, no problem. New pizza came out a little under to my liking but honestly it was pretty good. No discount or comp but we felt that was fair as the service was good and they dealt with it nicely. Fast forward to tonight. We decided to stop in for dinner. We were seated right away. Restaurant didn’t seem too busy. We waited for at least 20 minutes at the table. Nobody acknowledged our presence. Multiple waiters/waitresses walked around us, taking order from folks seated afterwards. At one point the host that seated us made direct eye contact with my girlfriend and still nothing. After over 25 minutes we decided to leave. We asked our host for a water to go and let him know that nobody had talked to us. He gave a very weak apology and that was that. We left with a sour taste in our mouths. I’ve heard such great things from many friends and family. It’s a shame we had a mediocre experience the first time and a downright terrible experience the second. I don’t think we will be giving SRP a third chance.
-
April 2024 by Shannon Johnson
Great service, menu choices and food!
-
April 2024 by Michaela Porth
Delicious! I'm glad they have a gluten free option!
-
March 2024 by Scott Salvinski
Pizza was great, Nicole was awesome bartender and gave great recommendations on food/drinks. My son said give them a 10 out of 10 review. We were here for kids basketball tournament in Verona, highly recommend you stop
-
March 2024 by JANE STAM
We had a party of 11. With a reservation we were seated promptly and had good service. Pizza is filling and tasty.
-
March 2024 by Grace Richardson
We had such a great time! Our food was incredible and our waiter, Marissa, was super awesome!
-
March 2024 by Kenneth Eads
Got to try SRPC out tonight! Came last night at 630pm and there was an hour wait. Before leaving we made a reservation for tonight. Pizza did not disappoint! Ordered a 14” hand tossed pepperoni, sausage and mushroom pie. I also had a salad with the house blue cheese dressing. 11/10! Best pizza I have had in a long time. The sauce is amazing. Our server Kailee was very professional and really knows the specialty pizzas. She was awesome! Definitely recommend a reservation. This place has a large following and I have watched folks exiting the place with stacks of pies since arriving! I absolutely recommend this place and Kailee!
-
March 2024 by Dawn Dwyer
Pizza was
