Casey's in Waterford, WI, located at 991 W Main St, offers popular pizza with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. Besides pizza, the store provides appetizers, sweets, drinks, groceries, and household essentials. Customers can also fuel up their vehicles with quality gasoline. The staff are friendly and the store is kept clean, making it a welcoming place. The rewards gas program is highly appreciated, especially for those who buy gas and pizza regularly. While some reviews mention issues like out-of-order credit card readers and empty window wash containers, overall, customers value the good service and clean environment. One customer appreciated the friendly staff who noticed their hearing difficulty and showed kindness, highlighting the welcoming atmosphere of this Casey's location.
Clean, easy access, well lit facility. Friendly staff. Good quick food.
January 2026
For a gas station, Casey's Pizza is a pleasant surprise! Fountain drinks are really good and not watered down and they have a great selection of snacks and pre made meal choices for people on the go
August 2024
Always friendly and best rewards gas station program I know. They add up quick when you get gas and pizza like I do. ?
