Bagelmakers offers large but fluffy bagels, which some still find more like bread. The cream cheese is marked as "lite," but the herb flavor has been compared to a cheap dip. Service is decent, and the young lady behind the counter is kind and patient. However, some customers feel that tables should be cleaner. The coffee is self-serve and might need improvement. Customers who ordered near closing time found limited options and ended up with a heavily salted bagel, making it hard to enjoy. Reducing the salt sprinkled on the bagels could make them tastier and healthier for everyone. Many have praised the bagels, with options like the Farmers Special with bacon and the Everything bagel receiving positive mentions. Customers have noted that the bagels are very fresh and generously topped, making them a delightful choice. Overall, Bagelmakers is a place that deserves a visit, especially for those in the area.
Best bagels around! They are incredibly fresh and taste exactly how an authentic bagel should.
December 2025
We tried the Farmers special and a Tex Mex burrito. The bagel was so nice, but the filling was a little bland. If you could pack the flavor from the burrito into the bagel, that would be hands down the best road trip breakfast option.
