Hotels in Newcastle, WY

6 locations found near Newcastle

“I had an amazing stay at the Sundowner Inn—easily a 5-star experience. This place truly stands out for its hospitality and the genuine care you feel from the moment you arrive. Scott and his wife have built something special here, and you can tell it’s a labor of love. Knowing the inn dates back to around 1910 just adds to its charm and character.

The entire place is beautiful, cozy, and incredibly comfortable. Everything feels fresh and updated—from the beds and sheets to the walls themselves. You get that perfect mix of historic charm with modern comfort.

The coffee was always fresh, and the breakfast they put out was not only delicious but also healthy, which I really appreciated. It’s those little details that make a big difference.

I would most definitely stay here again without hesitation. Thank you, Scott—you’re the man, brother!”

4.8 Superb79 Reviews

“The Pines Country Inn is a wonderful place to stay. The atmosphere is very peaceful and relaxing, perfect for anyone looking to unwind. The rooms are clean, comfortable, and well cared for. The manager is professional, friendly, and always attentive to guests’ needs. The service was excellent from check-in to checkout. I highly recommend The Pines Country Inn for its calm environment and outstanding hospitality.”

4.5 Superb85 Reviews

“Mallo motel set out in the beautiful black hills offers a rustic charm to enjoy nature while still having basic amenities like a kitchen, showers, and some WiFi for calls and tv. If you are looking for camping or a room to have after a day of hunting, fishing, utv exploring or snowmobiling, This is a great place to go. The caretakers are super friendly a do a great job.”

4.7 Superb28 Reviews

“The rooms are nostalgic, very clean! Cozy cabin like feel, with quilts on the beds. The gentleman that runs it was friendly and kind as can be. He also suggested a restaurant for us to dine at which we could get an awesome steak that would melt in your mouth, and he wasn't wrong. He had us try the Pizza Barn. Really enjoyed our stay.”

4.5 Superb48 Reviews

“Crystal was all above and behold and the whole staff took care of making this evening an awesome experience. I'm so pleased to recommend this place due to such a good customer service. Food quality was good and customer service was top notch. 100% recommended.”

3.7 Good79 Reviews

“Great place to stay if you are working or traveling, has a bar ?, close to Taco John's and truck stop, town is small enough that everything is minutes away. Nice island in the middle of the pond.”

3.2 Average54 Reviews