Overtime Sports is a highly regarded local shop known for its friendly atmosphere and excellent selection of sports memorabilia and cards. Customers appreciate the welcoming environment, with staff greeting regulars by name and making visitors feel like family. The shop offers a wide variety of items, including Pokémon Cards, sports memorabilia, jerseys, and vintage cards, which many describe as the best they have seen. The vintage card collection is especially praised, with visitors noting it as one of the best they've encountered across the country. The owner and staff are friendly, helpful, and dedicated to providing outstanding customer service. Many customers highlight the shop’s fair prices and the positive experience of chatting and browsing for hours. The shop’s setup evokes a nostalgic feel reminiscent of the 80s and 90s, making it a favorite for true collectors and travelers alike. Overall, Overtime Sports is celebrated as a great place to find quality sports collectibles and enjoy a welcoming environment.
Love this place! Everyone is really friendly and greet you by name when you become a regular. Great group of people. I enjoy their selection of both Pokémon Cards and Sports Memorabilia. They also carry jerseys and have a great selection.
December 2025
I found a 1957 Bill Martin. The owner was a good guy.
September 2025
Always love coming here. Super friendly staff and great selection of cards!
