Casey's in Tontitown, AR, offers convenient pizza delivery and pickup with made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. Customers can enjoy a variety of snacks, sweet treats, drinks, household essentials, and groceries. The location also features a fuel station with quality fuels, and the staff is friendly and attentive. Many reviews highlight the friendly service from the manager and kitchen staff, who remain busy yet polite. The kitchen is usually clean, and food is prepared quickly with a smile. While the pizza and snacks are popular, some find the prices a bit high, especially for coffees. The gas station provides a good experience for fueling, though cleanliness and drink options can vary. Overall, Casey’s is a reliable spot for quick stops, tasty food, and fuel, with friendly service making visits enjoyable.
Best pizza, best Casey’s around. We actually live closer to another Casey’s in the area but we always order pizza from this one. Andrea makes a great pizza in 9 minutes and provides excellent customer service.
March 2025
Great Casey's. I had to go in for a fuel receipt and the cashier actually apologized for my inconvenience. There has never been a gas station to do that before. Amazing. Thank you.
January 2025
Casey's is always good for a quick stop, snacks fuel,pizza,coffees a little expensive, 4.00 for a small. May have to go to Starbucks for that price1🤣🤣
