Central Bay Coin Exchange is a highly regarded business specializing in buying and selling rare coins, gold and silver bullion, and old currency. With over 30 years of combined experience, the team is dedicated to providing a seamless and fair experience for customers. Reviews highlight the friendly and welcoming atmosphere, with quick responses to inquiries and a willingness to help sort through various inherited items. Customers appreciate the fair pricing and knowledgeable staff, who take the time to educate them about numismatics. Many have expressed satisfaction with their visits, noting the relaxed conversations and enthusiasm for coins. The store is recommended for those looking to buy or sell, as it offers competitive prices that surpass other options in the area. Central Bay Coin Exchange stands out as a trusted destination for anyone interested in precious metals and coins in Santa Cruz County.
All my experiences here so far have been exceptionally good. Earlier in the year I came in and bought some silver coins on a couple different occasions. Then today I went there and sold a gram of gold. They paid me spot - $5 the way it should be. You have a customer for life.
January 2026
These guys are great. Very honest & knowledgeable. We do business with them often. Always very fair!
November 2025
Friendly, efficient services and fair pricing. I definitely recommend them.
