The Inn at 2nd & C is a charming historic boutique hotel located in Old Town Eureka, known for its vibrant atmosphere. Guests have enjoyed staying at this funky hotel, which features Gallagher's Irish-themed restaurant and Phatsy Clines cocktail lounge, where local bands often perform. The building's beauty captivates visitors, and the rooms are clean and comfortable, with some offering great amenities like working windows and strong shower pressure. While many guests have praised the friendly and accommodating staff, some noted minor issues with communication, particularly regarding reservations made through third-party platforms. A mix-up regarding room types left one group surprised, but the owner addressed their concerns personally and offered a generous solution for a future stay. Noise levels from the bustling streets and the restaurant below were mentioned by a few guests, though sound machines are available in the rooms. Overall, the Inn at 2nd & C provides a wonderful experience for those looking to explore Eureka's history, with helpful staff ready to recommend local attractions. Visitors are encouraged to book directly with the hotel to avoid any potential miscommunications and to support the local business.
It's a funky, historic hotel in Old Town Eureka anchored by Gallagher's an Irish-themed restaurant, and Phatsy Clines cocktail lounge where local bands play music. .
July 2025
It was my first time being here and I loved the building, inside and out. I wish I could have explored more but maybe another time.
July 2025
Great place to stay. Centrally located and quiet. I will go back again
