Citadel Game Cellar is a well-loved and highly recommended game store known for its vast and diverse selection of games and paraphernalia. Visitors often comment on the impressive size of the collection, which includes thousands of board games across all genres, as well as model painting supplies. The store is well organized, making it easier for customers to find what they are looking for, despite some initial concerns about the overwhelming variety. The staff are consistently praised for being friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful—they are quick to assist and willing to provide recommendations or explain game rules. Many customers appreciate the welcoming atmosphere, noting that they felt no pressure to purchase and enjoyed trying open box games in the shop, often at no extra charge. The owner is also seen as a friendly, approachable person who enjoys talking about games. Visitors often discover new games they wouldn’t have found elsewhere and leave with a positive experience, eager to return. Overall, Citadel Game Cellar stands out as a top destination for game enthusiasts, offering a great selection, helpful staff, and a fun, welcoming environment that keeps customers coming back whenever they are in the area.
Been going here with my son and my friends for years, great place
June 2026
Love this place! So many hard to find games are jam-packed onto the shelves. Found a game that's been out of print for a few years in the back room. Ironically, they did not have the original Forest Shuffle game in stock when I went. It's worth the one hour drive to get to this place once every few months.
June 2026
HUGE selection of rpg books, minis, paint, board games, card games. Staff was friendly and helpful Space inside to play and learn games.
