Big Y in New Milford is a trusted local supermarket and one of the best grocery stores in the area, serving the community with a top-notch shopping experience. The store is large, bright, well-organized, clean, and inviting, making it a convenient and enjoyable destination for all grocery needs. It is a true one-stop shop with an outstanding selection. This includes a produce section well-stocked with fresh fruits and vegetables, often with organic and local options, and impressive meat and seafood departments with quality cuts. The bakery is noted as the best, with fresh bread, pastries, and cakes that taste great and look amazing. The store carries a great selection of pantry items, specialty foods, and prepared meals. Big Y's commitment is to providing fresh and local products and excellent customer service. The staff are friendly, approachable, and always willing to help, making the experience special. Checkout is smooth and efficient. While prices are a bit high, you are getting good quality, and the store offers competitive prices and regular discounts. Customers can rack up points and stack up savings with myBigY Rewards. Big Y is more than just a supermarket, balancing big-store variety with personal customer service for a stress-free experience where you’ll leave impressed.
Every year I use the Big Y bakery to design a cake for the presentation of our school trip to Outdoor Classroom. The cakes are always beautiful, but this year the design literally takes the cake. I talked to the person who designed it and she said she loved the opportunity to be creative. A hidden treasure at Big Y. Thank... read full comment
June 2026
Sunday early if you can manage. I try to go btwn 7-8am. The best deals and the shelves haven't been pillaged quite yet.
April 2026
This is a big store with great selection, but it is pricey.
