Pegasus Coin and Jewelry is a well-established business, led by John Maben, who has been a professional numismatist since 1978. With extensive experience, including roles at NGC and PCGS, John ensures high standards in buying and selling coins and jewelry. The staff, including knowledgeable salesman Art, are friendly, helpful, and trustworthy, making customers feel welcome and valued. Many reviews highlight the excellent customer service and expertise provided, with clients appreciating the thorough explanations of transactions. Pegasus is recognized as an Official NGC, PCGS, and ICTA dealer and holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, reflecting their commitment to quality service. Customers consistently recommend Pegasus for all coin and jewelry needs, noting that their experiences surpass those at other stores. Overall, Pegasus Coin and Jewelry stands out for its knowledgeable staff and friendly atmosphere, making it a top choice for buying or selling precious items.
I went a second time to Pegasus Coin and Jewelry recently. Professional attention and service. Knowledgeable staff members. Fair price received. Highly recommended. Five stars rating.
September 2026
Honest and professional. They were very knowledgeable and informative. I took some coins in to sell and they treated me well and gave me a very good price.
August 2026
This establishment is the very best! They gave us courteous service and the best price in Manatee County. I will definitely return. Thank you for everything.