Auto Insurance in Fort Myers, FL

28 locations found near Fort Myers
View Map

“I moved to Florida in 2012. My first Insurance agency was terrible and I discovered after one year that my house hadn't and wasn't insured. Cars were. That bad company said they could get me coverage sometime the next day. I walked out of that office and went straight to East and Greenwell. Within one hour I walked out of their office with my house insured. One doesn't forget a kindness like that.We now have 5 rental properties, our home and two cars all insured through East & Greenwell. The office staff is really really helpful and knowledgeable. Their service is prompt, professionally done and done with a smile.I have nothing but good things to say about East & Greenwell and AllState. Go with them. You will be pleased and well served.We are now in our 12th year with them. I don't plan to every switch.”

4.8 Superb101 Reviews

“Melissa provided me with first-class top-Notch and professional service, answered all my questions and resolved my situation without difficulties, I recommend her 150% and her office too that has already offered me their services for 8 years. Thank you Melissa!!! Never change , and maintain that patience and joy that many employees in the Customer Service branch have lost today.”

5 Superb46 Reviews

“I had a problem and called to cancel. I wanted to be frustrated not thinking they would fix it. To my surprise not only did they fix it, they went above and beyond. I spoke to a lady on the phone. Unfortunately I don’t remember her name.”

4.9 Superb62 Reviews

“Recently, as part of a plan to consolidate my insurance providers, I reached out to Nick Glaeser's office for State Farm Insurance. My call was taken by Erick Joseph, agent. Not only did he provide quotes in an efficient timeframe, he helped me navigate new products and plan configurations that meet my needs the very best! Erick has extensive knowledge of the State Farm products which makes the process of product plan selection all the more simple. He was engaging and interested in helping me get to "the finish line" in this process - in a proactive, positive, manner. He is the model of what I wanted to experience - my "neighborhood" insurance professional....having a contact I can meet with as needed within a company that has a long-term, reliable reputation. Erick is a wonderful representative for Nick Glaeser's State Farm Office and I am delighted to have him as my professional insurance contact. Thank you!”

4.8 Superb53 Reviews

“Being a snowbird and unsure of the US insurance market, Tom took time to explain our options. He answered all our questions and walked us through the entire process of obtaining home insurance. Some people just go out of their way to be helpful, and you are one of them! It's nice to work with people who are responsive and efficient - not easy to find today!”

5 Superb30 Reviews

“I was freaking out cuz I only read part of my renewal email and thought it was good to go until a friend told me nope you have to call to keep them. I called today and spoke with David Smith and that man is awesome. He said I wasn't late calling in like I thought I was and was very patient answering my questions. He asked if I have received me insurance cards and I said not sure cuz checking my mail box is another thing I slack at. He told me no worries and emailed them to me. Direct Auto you guys are very lucky to have David Smith. Very polite, patient and very helpful. In my book that man is awesome. Thank you David for all the help ?”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews

“I've been going to the insurance man for 8 years and Jasmin takes good care for me. She has been great since day one. Office is very clean. Staff is professional. Highly recommend.”

4.9 Superb30 Reviews

“It was an absolute pleasure to work with Evan. Communication was extremely clear, he walked us through all the details of our car insurance, and he saved us money. My only regret is not going with them sooner.”

4.9 Superb28 Reviews

“Nely was really helpful when I called in to make a payment she also helped me update my phone number and address and informed me of my new lower rate with the address change.”

4.7 Superb49 Reviews

“Amazing service and they are super helpful. I am really hard for finding insurance and they helped me solve the riddle with amazing courtesy and professionalism. Thank you. ??”

4.7 Superb35 Reviews

“I had the absolute best experience with Jamie!! I have been speaking to her about switching my Auto insurance. She worked for about a hour finding me the best price! She found a company which would save me over 200 dollars a month!! I'll spare the details but we hit a few bumps while doing this. This girl came through and ended up getting me insurance cheaper than originally quoted! She is a hard and dedicated agent for her customers! I know if she did this for me, she will do it for anyone! Above and beyond service! I will be sending her referrals for sure!! 5 star service! A++ Thank you Jamie at SWFL insurance!!!”

4.6 Superb37 Reviews

“Dear Gina Wittwer,We, the Montgomery family, are writing to express our profound appreciation for your exceptional service and dedication during the recent hurricane that impacted Fort Myers and Cape Coral. Your work as a representative of Nash and Associates was nothing short of exemplary.In the face of adversity and chaos, your professionalism shone through. Navigating insurance matters during such a challenging time can be overwhelming for many, but your expertise and guidance made all the difference. What we found most commendable was your consistent availability. At a time when reaching out for assistance seemed almost impossible, you were always there, ready to provide support and answers.Your ability to offer expert advice and clarity in a situation fraught with uncertainty helped us manage what could have been an unbearable ordeal. In the aftermath of the hurricane, where situations often seem bleak, your role as a mediator was crucial. You were a beacon of hope, offering not just accurate and timely information, but also comfort and reassurance.Your dedication to your profession is admirable. The compassion, efficiency, and thoroughness you displayed are qualities that set you apart in your field. It is rare to encounter someone who so skillfully balances professional responsibilities with genuine care and empathy.We extend our heartfelt thanks for your exceptional service during this difficult period. Your efforts have had a significant impact on us and will be remembered with great appreciation.With warm regards,The Montgomery Family”

4.7 Superb24 Reviews

“Danay was great. She assured me that I would be happy with her service and I was. I would recommend Estrella Insurance and Danay to anyone looking for great great service.”

4.8 Superb18 Reviews

“Stephanie Sherman was extremely helpful in the insurance process. She communicated and explained all of my options clearly and efficiently. She was always available as a resource for me, and made the purchasing of insurance so easy and smooth. Would highly recommend asking for Stephanie for any of your insurance needs!”

4.7 Superb18 Reviews

“Ive been with State Farm Art Roberts for over 20 years .I love the staff and have had the company bat for me when I needed them .Thank you Mr Art Roberts for the kind ladies working for you !”

5 Superb9 Reviews

“Excellent. I called to check out other carriers for insurance and everything was explained to me very well and was very patient with me - now my husband and I are so happy to be with Larry Snider and State Farm!”

4.5 Superb22 Reviews

“The only thing I'm not happy with, you're agents, has too send notifications too , our reverse mortgageCompany, they Tex us that they don't receive! Notification that we have insurance with you! Rubina & Nickloas Mallous!”

4.3 Superb51 Reviews

“I can’t even begin to explain the level of attention and customer service provided by Dave and his office. Just through a few phone calls, ALL of which the owner himself, always was readily available to take my call. I really got the feeling like he treated me the way you would treat a family member. He saved me over $100 a month and got me better coverage than any other company could’ve in all of the 25 years I’ve been driving. I recommend him and his company to anyone looking for a great price and even more amazing Customer Service.”

4.3 Superb29 Reviews

“The staff was very professional and helpful with the insurance coverage that was needed . I highly recommend this office to take care of any of your insurance concerns! Thank you!”

4.4 Superb17 Reviews

“I would like recognize Travis for going above and beyond. We are under construction on our new home and requested a flood insurance estimate from Chapman Insurance Company. When we received the policy estimate, we were very surprised by the annual cost. I immediately connected with Travis and he spent time explaining all the details of the estimate and the reasons why the estimate was so high. However, he did not stop there, Travis took the initiative at 4:45pm on Friday afternoon to dig into the reason further. After working with the underwriter until 5:30 he realized the Elevation Certificate was incorrect and was negatively impacting our policy. We would not have identified this error if it was not for Travis. He went above beyond by taking the time to review every detail, connecting with the underwriter and then effectively communicating back to me what I need to do to revise the Elevation Certificate after hours on a Friday evening. I appreciate Travis for being a great partner and I would like to thank him for his time working with me to secure a Flood Insurance Policy.”

4.5 Superb10 Reviews

“I didn't deal with them in person, but I got through on the phone. No hassle and I just needed basic information. They were very sensitive to my time and patience. 10/10 they were great.”

4.2 Good30 Reviews

“We had a roofing claim due to damage caused by Hurricane Ian...it was settled and paid within a week...they even installed a blue tarp faster!!! Excellent response and Customer Service!!!”

4.3 Superb14 Reviews

“Hallie was so helpful on the phone today! She helped me better understand my insurance coverage and payment plan. She made me actually enjoy calling the insurance company, which most would agree is a feat :)”

4.5 Superb7 Reviews

“State Insurance with Blake, Josh, and Linda have helped over the years to have the right coverage for my ever changing needs. They have helped me with personal home and vehicle coverage and helped navigate the world of business GL and WC, and even classic cars.I would recommend Blake, Josh and team to my friends, and trust them with my family’s needs. Oh yeah, already did that last year as we reached to Josh to help arrange coverage for my Mom’s new condo.”

4.2 Good24 Reviews

“My first impression was the phone answered everytime no voice mail and friendly ongoing staff that knew my name and verified me every time. In addition, Christy and Danielle answered every question and provided professional advice so that I can make the enhancing decision needed to help me save money in this insurance world of high premiums, fraud, and little to no companies writing in the state of Florida. This is my new insurance company now and in the future.”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“Dave went absolutely above and beyond getting us home insurance. He worked overtime on a Friday to make sure we had insurance in time to close on our new home. He got us the best rate we found shopping around by far. If you need insurance, definitely give Dave a call!”

4.3 Superb8 Reviews

“I have had the pleasure of working with Wilcox Family Insurance for three years. Due to the hurricane in FL my home owners insurance pulled out of FL. Paul at Wilcox found me another carrier at a reasonable rate. I highly recommend Wilcox Family Insurance. They are the simply the BEST.”

4.1 Good9 Reviews

You May Also Like