Amara Cay Resort in Islamorada, Florida offers a wonderful vacation experience for guests. The hotel staff is consistently praised as exceptional, with reviewers highlighting the friendly, helpful, and attentive service provided by employees like Amber, Marcus, Krissan, Abner, Jackie, Omar, Aliton, and Dillip. Many note the staff made their stays stress-free and enjoyable. The resort itself earns high marks, with clean, spacious rooms and well-maintained grounds. Guests appreciate the variety of on-site amenities and dining options, as well as the convenience of the shuttle service between the resort's three locations. Several reviewers mention the delicious food and drinks, including Marcus' acclaimed espresso martinis. The resort's location is also cited as a strength, with nearby restaurants, activities like boating and fishing, and scenic views all within easy reach. Reviewers feel safe and comfortable walking around the property. Overall, Amara Cay Resort provides a wonderful vacation experience, with top-notch customer service, quality accommodations, and ample amenities. Guests consistently rank it among the best hotels they've visited, and many look forward to returning for another stay.
We had a extremely relaxing stay at Amara Cay. The pool is beautiful, water temperature perfect. The food at Amara is also delicious. We enjoyed the ice water with fruit that was always available. The lobby could use some sprucing up. All the staff especially by the bar outside were very helpful. I will definitely go back.
January 2026
We just came here to have a late lunch, the food was soooo good and fresh seafood. The service was great too, but the best part is sitting by the fireplaces after eating bad just unwinding back with dessert or a cocktail.
January 2026
We were welcomed by Chloe and shebwas amazing. Great experience
