Jewelry Stores in Key West, FL

30 locations found near Key West
View Map

“Title: Unplanned Elegance at Ballerina JewelryDuring our visit to Key West, a casual stop at Ballerina Jewelry turned into an unexpected upgrade for my wedding ring. Rajesh, the store representative, impressed us with his kindness and knowledge. He patiently guided us through a stunning selection of marquise natural diamonds, allowing us the space to decide without pressure.After a thoughtful dinner discussion with friends, we returned to find the perfect ring. Rajesh’s professionalism and the exquisite collection made this spontaneous upgrade a magical experience. If you’re in Key West and appreciate fine jewelry, Ballerina Jewelry is a must-visit. Thank you, Rajesh, for making this unexpected journey unforgettable.”

5 Superb96 Reviews

“We had a great time shopping with Peter and Gary at Bliss Jewelers in Key West. They are professional, knowledgeable, and fun to be with!!! They will always be our go to for fine and high quality jewelry.Jean and Tom”

5 Superb56 Reviews

“I was drawn through the door as I walked down Duval Street! What an amazing experience to be able to be that close to such amazing history! My kids, wife and I were given a history lesson of this amazing find! I wish we were able to bring a piece of this history home but unfortunately not everyone can be so lucky. Thanks for the great experience!”

4.9 Superb68 Reviews

“We were very pleased with the service. We are in the UK and this was the first time we have bought jewellery internationally. Carl was very helpful, confirming exactly what we were buying, giving us confidence that it would all go smoothly and keeping in touch throughout. Very happy to recommend them.”

5 Superb32 Reviews

“Very nice staff hosting this small quaint shop with many trinkets and souvenirs. I would have purchased more if I didn't have capacity issues to deal with on the return home. So many neat things to choose from.My wife and I ended up getting some mints and a funny cup for her sister. I would definitely recommend stopping here.”

4.9 Superb37 Reviews

“Wendy, Brian and Alex are the absolute best you won’t find a better place in the Keys the service was unbelievable! They're super friendly and ready to help you in an instant with any of your jewelry needs and there’s no pressure at all!!”

4.7 Superb66 Reviews

“After my mother's death, I brought him all my mother's and grandmother's jewelry to look at and assess. I brought many pieces that needed repairs or watch batteries. I even brought him a silver tea set to repair. Jeff was very kind, fair, and professional. In my time of grief, he was the jeweler I needed. Even though he's nautical, he's definitely not a shark. Thank you on the behalf of my family. All the pieces you repaired are beautiful.”

4.7 Superb63 Reviews

“You guys have the best and most beautiful, bracelets I've come across in a long time.my sister got a few while visiting there then I ordered a few and then ordered a few more..they last forever..I never take them off.Very reasonable priced and very detailed. Thanks for the work and love you put into them Tammie Dutton”

5 Superb19 Reviews

“I love this store, but the customer service representatives are a little over the top. Maybe it is a millennial thing, where it’s perceived that customers want to be engaged and interactive, but I just want to go in by myself and look around without being bothered.Every single worker came up to me to try to talk to me, compliment me, point out items they thought I would like, asked me personal questions, and even offered to “accessorize my look”. I really just wanted to be left alone but it seems they didn’t catch on. I was actually interested in buying a thing or two but ended up leaving in a hurry because I felt mildly harassed. It was just too much.”

4.6 Superb78 Reviews

“Barb and her beautiful baubles have been in Key West a long time. She is wonderful! Personal attention and so many amazing things to choose from. Highly recommend Barb and her shop to anyone wanting unique, one-of-a-kind pieces, and above and beyond service.”

4.8 Superb26 Reviews

“Went to Mine Shaft Designs to purchase some jewelry for a Birthday gift. Antonio was amazing and took his time to show me what I was looking for exactly. He also made a special piece to put on my necklace that my husband gave me for our 40th Anniversary this year. I highly recommend Mine Shaft Designs on Greene St. They are very nice, professional and caring.”

4.8 Superb24 Reviews

“What a wonderful shop!!! Jen is not only a wonderful small business owner, but a fellow master artisan. She is as passionate about each of the local artists as she is her own wonderful jewelry. Go past the gift shops with imported products and stop in to a locally ran, supported and filled gallery of one-of-a-kind pieces that are to die for! We felt so welcomed and we love that Jen is making this space available for the local artists.We came down from Clearwater and happened upon this gem!”

4.9 Superb16 Reviews

“Sophia is so talented in making her custom jewelry pieces! Sophia and Kim can create anything you would like in jewelry with beautiful results. Thank you so much!”

5 Superb9 Reviews

“I had the best possible experience buying a bracelet for my daughter. We chatted with the owner who was extremely accommodating to us both. She really worked to understand my daughter’s style and interests. The pieces she created were perfect. We will definitely visit again next time we are in town!”

4.6 Superb21 Reviews

“Stopped in to grab my wife an ankle bracelet. Found exactly what she wanted but I Left my bag of souvenirs on the counter and didn’t realize till we got back to key largo I left it behind.Drove back the following day and bought an 2nd round of shirts and gifts.Stopped at local color and the owner had my original stuff behind the counter. Wound up having a great 2nd day in key west.A small amount of my faith in humanity was restored.Thank you”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“Sean the owner is Awesome! ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Great price for items sold. Sean is Friendly, Professional, Knowledgeable and Honest! I will definitely be back. Thank you! ?”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“We have done business with Silver & Gold in Key West over many years. We've consistently found them the be honest, willing to be reasonably flexible on pricing, pleasant and low-key to deal with and have a large inventory of affordable, attractive jewelry. We highly recommend them!”

4.7 Superb10 Reviews

“Thank you Tiffany for getting me fitted with super cute toe rings! I learned a lot and enjoyed the experience. I’d highly recommend them as they know what they’re doing!!”

4.3 Superb67 Reviews

“Please ignore the negative reviews about this store, they are clearly written by people who have no idea what quality means. If you want to shop for unique items in a gorgeous setting, then this is your place. It's not a place for drunken tourists who want a tshirt or a post card. It's clear the owners have put their heart into curating everything about the store. OK, the price point is a little higher but get over it. The prices are not over the top for the items they are. Also the people working there are kind and knowledgeable. So, if you want some flip flops and a post card go to the CVS. If you want to spend some time fantasizing about beautiful, amazing smelling , high quality items to add to your life- check out our favorite boutique in Key West”

4.4 Superb23 Reviews

“My ONLY must "stop to shop" place in the Keys! Keir never disappoints us, finding new styles and prints in clothes than anybody else in Key West. Although I still wear my dresses and shirts from my first visit over 10hrs ago. My home, dock, and closet has so many Dragonfly items but cannot wait to see what this year brings home”

4.7 Superb7 Reviews

“I LOVE everything in this store. While the prices are quite high they do markdowns and the quality of their clothing is worth it. The customer service was amazing as well. The lady that helped me with my purchase was very down to earth and was helpful without being pushy. I follow them on Facebook and get notifications on their upcoming sales to make it a lot more affordable. Since I am trying to focus on quality clothing over quantity this has got to be my favorite little boutique in Key West.”

5 Superb3 Reviews

“Super friendly staff and lovely boutique! Wonderful jewelry galore. You will definitely find the best jewelry gifts for everyone here. Plenty of price ranges and the staff is helpful and will even check their other locations if you are looking for something specific. Worth the look!”

4.4 Superb8 Reviews

“wow, a jewelry store with real jewelers on site who know what they're doing!! they have one of the best hand-made gold charm and pendant collections I've ever seen. also stunning coin pendants, chains, and jemstones! Jan custom made a piece and it was perfect! prices were very fair and quality superior to any other store in Key West”

4.2 Good13 Reviews

“Good selection of "coins". --- which of course I had to buy one. The story of Mel Fisher and his search for this shipwreck is amazing. We will be back! Go enjoy.”

4.1 Good17 Reviews

“I have been shopping at Conch Jewelers for a few years now and I always enjoy our experience. John and the rest of staff are great and welcoming, and the quality and prices of their jewelry is amazing. I’m very happy with their knowledge and customer service and always recommend them to our family and friends! Thank you, Conch Jewelers!”

4.1 Good7 Reviews

“Capricorn is always a stop on our trips to KW. We’ve been stopping in for the past 15 years and are always satisfied with the customer service. If you want a piece of jewelry with a special feel of Key West, you need to stop in.”

3.9 Good34 Reviews

“Been to Key West several times but never heard of Bone Island so we had to check it out. Glad we did. Our Guide John was entertaining and had us creeped out with awesome ghost stories and fascinating legends of Key West. Turns out Bone Island is just another name for Key West! We had a great time. You won't be disappointed.”

1 Poor1 Reviews

“Excellent customer sevice! I got engaged in another state and with little time left in Key West in needed to have it resized. I walked in and Rishi greeted me with a smile at the front desk and ensured me it could be done by the end of the next day! It was ready as promised, done perfectly and for a great deal. I highly recomend this shop.”

1 Poor1 Reviews

Jewelry Stores in The Nearby Cities