Hinckley's Fancy Meats is a highly acclaimed scratch kitchen known for its sandwiches and charcuterie made from sustainable ingredients sourced from small farms. Recognized as Orlando Sentinel's Best Sandwich Winner in 2020, 2021, and 2023, and featured in USA Today's 10 Best, the business has also received the MSN Award for Best Bacon in Florida and was included in the NY Times Holiday Gift Buying Guide. The establishment offers a selection of over 80 craft beers, including local options, and features a refrigerated cabinet with a variety of pates. Customers praise the quality and creativity of the menu, highlighting standout items like the Cuban sandwich and a bacon bourbon masterpiece. The sandwiches are described as delicious, extravagant, and even life-changing, with some reviews mentioning the exceptional quality of meats such as duck bacon and pastrami that rival well-known northeastern styles. The staff is consistently noted for being friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful, offering advice and excellent service. In addition to its inventive menu, Hinckley's provides fresh baked sourdough bread and a rotating selection of new items to keep customers intrigued. Overall, it is considered a must-visit spot for those seeking high-quality sandwiches, craft beers, and a welcoming atmosphere, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
The Chicken Pesto sandwich is delicious and fully reaches the historically high standards of Hinckley’s! I highly recommend it.
May 2026
You go there for the sandwiches but there’s always something new added to keep your interest whether it’s a new sando or something in the deli case like a new cheese to try. The fish tins are getting more popular and easy to grab and go for later.
April 2026
I ordered thru Instacart. OMG, the Beef on Weck was fantastic. I did not get the chips I ordered.
